City Council Meeting - February 01, 2011

×

Meeting Summary

A
Roll Call 📄
The meeting was called to order by Mayor Herb Weiner, who welcomed attendees to the Tuesday, February 1st, 2011 meeting. A roll call was conducted, with Councilmember Pfeiffer, Councilmember Leon, Councilmember Ford, and Mayor Weiner all present 📄 - 📄. Dr. Thornton then led the Pledge of Allegiance 📄 - 📄. Following the pledge, Mayor Weiner indicated an intent to move the consent calendar 📄.
4
CONSENT CALENDAR 📄
The consent calendar was introduced without any discussion or presentation from councilmembers. The Mayor indicated readiness to move the consent items 📄.
E
Approval of Agenda 📄
Herb Weiner noted there was no public comment on the agenda approval 📄. Jonathan Leone and Linda Pfeifer moved and seconded the approval 📄. Herb Weiner called for a vote, with no opposition noted 📄. After approval, there was light discussion about the meeting being televised and a new TV camera for internet streaming, with Jonathan Leone reassuring attendees they are not being monitored like in Timberon 📄.
Motion
Motion to approve the agenda, moved by Jonathan Leone and seconded by Linda Pfeifer, passed with no opposition 📄.
A
Acknowledgement of those Sausalito-Marin City School District students reaching the '900 Club' (Intern David Weatherford, Superintendent Debra Bradley and Mayor Weiner) - 7:05 PM 📄
Intern David Weatherford introduces the '900 Club' recognition for students achieving a combined score of 900 or higher on English Language Arts and Math standardized tests from Bayside Elementary, MLK Academy, and Willow Creek Academy. Superintendent Debra Bradley explains the significance, noting the state previously set a bar of 800, making 900 a notable achievement 📄. School board members and Willow Creek Academy head Carol Cooper are introduced. Mayor Weiner and councilmembers Pfeifer, Ford, and Leone congratulate the students, expressing pride and emphasizing community unity across the Sausalito-Marin City area 📄, 📄, 📄. Superintendent Bradley then reads the names of recognized students from grades 3 through 8, with certificates distributed.
4
CONSENT CALENDAR 📄
The meeting transitions to public comments on non-agenda items, with Herb Weiner noting two names, starting with Amy Blakeney 📄. No presentation or discussion specific to the Consent Calendar item occurred in the provided transcript segment.
2
COMMUNICATIONS 📄
Amy Blakeney, a board member of FireSafe Marin, presented on fire safety and beautification along Highway 101. She requested: 1) a letter of support from the City of Sausalito to Caltrans for an interregional transportation enhancement project to remove exotic invasive species and plant native vegetation to reduce wildfire risk 📄; 2) assistance in applying for a FireSafe Council matching grant for restoration of an eight-acre site off Rodeo Drive by April 1st 📄; 3) removal of eucalyptus and exotic vegetation from city-owned property to lead by example 📄; and 4) dialogue with GGNRA to permanently remove non-native trees from eastern slopes bordering Sausalito and Marin City 📄. John Flavin followed with questions about pension calculations from a previous meeting, seeking clarification on gross dollar changes from 2011-2012 to 2016-2017 and details on a CalPERS buyout figure of $43 million, asking if it was gross or net and if it included a 7% markup 📄.
Public Comment 2 1 In Favor 1 Neutral
4
CONSENT CALENDAR 📄
Councilmember Carolyn Ford moved to approve the consent calendar. Councilmember Jonathan Leone sought clarification on item 4C regarding the need for outside counsel for the Saucyde Boat Yard project. City Manager Mary Wagner explained that the item approves a legal services agreement with Best Best and Krieger, specifically to continue utilizing Linda Backman's expertise in public contracting assistance, as her previous firm disbanded. She provided examples of her work on the Sausalito Yacht Harbor bid process and public safety building. Leone confirmed the focus is on public contract bidding law and compliance, not negotiations. 📄
Motion
Motion to approve the consent calendar, seconded and passed unanimously. 📄
A
Housing Element Update Status Report (Associate Planner Lilly Schinsing) 📄
Associate Planner Lilly Schinsing presented a status update on the Housing Element Update, including a revised roadmap/work schedule approved by the Housing Element Committee (HEC). The roadmap outlines tasks, deadlines, and responsibilities for completing the housing element, including public workshops, site inventory, goals/policies/programs, and environmental review. 📄 Councilmember Leone questioned the timing of evaluating past housing elements (1995 and draft 2005/2006) and suggested incorporating successful past programs earlier; Schinsing clarified the evaluation is ongoing and will be reviewed by HEC on February 28th. 📄 Discussion focused on the facilitator selection for the first public workshop: HEC recommended a subcommittee (Vice Chair Cox and member Steve Flahive) to work with staff to select a facilitator. 📄 Councilmembers debated whether staff or the subcommittee should have final say on facilitator selection, with concerns about politicization and efficiency. 📄 Councilmember Pfeifer emphasized empowering resident committee members, while Councilmember Kelly and Leone stressed that staff should drive decisions and be accountable. 📄 Councilmember Ford moved to accept the HEC recommendations as presented, but after extensive debate, a substitute motion was made and voted on.
Motion
A motion was made by Councilmember Leone and seconded by Vice Mayor Kelly to approve the roadmap, workshop, agenda, and noticing options as presented by staff, with the caveat that staff makes the final recommendation on facilitator selection (after soliciting input from the HEC subcommittee). 📄 The motion passed 3-2 with Councilmembers Leone, Kelly, and Weiner voting yes; Councilmembers Ford and Pfeifer voting no. 📄
B
Street Repair List, 2011 Fiscal Year Preliminary Work Plan including Storm Drain Repairs 📄
City Engineer Todd Teachout presented the preliminary work plan for the 2011 street repair program, developed with CSG, totaling $738,000 but trimmed to a budget of $509,000 with some streets as add alternates. 📄 The plan includes dig-outs (structural patches), slurry seals (surface treatment for moderately good roads extending life 5-7 years), and overlays (lasting about 20 years with maintenance). 📄 Key points: Sausalito Boulevard drainage issues will be addressed via pavement re-profiling and driveway modifications; a minor slope repair near Ebtide is included; San Carlos Avenue needs coordinated sewer and pavement work (sewer costs separate). 📄, 📄, 📄 Council discussion included: Councilmember Leone clarified dig-outs and add alternates, asked about sewer funding impacts and project scalability, and confirmed public ownership of streets like Harbor Drive and Marin Shipway. 📄, 📄, 📄, 📄 Mayor Weiner inquired about Third Street utility work delays. 📄 Councilmember Leone questioned funding source for the slope repair, suggesting exploration of other capital funds. 📄 Staff will refine plans and return in March for approval before advertising.
Motion
Motion to accept the 2011 fiscal year street repair list plan, bifurcated to separate South Street and Third Street due to councilmember recusals. First part passed unanimously. Second part for South and Third Streets passed with Councilmembers Leon and Pfeifer recused, and the three remaining councilmembers in favor. 📄, 📄
C
Non-Motorized Transportation Pilot Program Projects Status Update (City Engineer Todd Teachout) 📄
City Engineer Todd Teachout provided updates on three NMTPP projects: 1) Gate 6 Road to Ferry Landing Path Plan/Feasibility Study (draft completed, public workshop held, comments received, final report to return to council next meeting) 📄. 2) Ferry Landing to Bridgeway Improvement Project (design complete, submitted to Caltrans for environmental review and funding, aiming for spring or post-September construction) 📄. 3) Sausalito Stairs Project (focus on Filbert Stairs, easements secured, environmental review with Caltrans in progress) 📄. Teachout also mentioned seeking additional Safety Loo funds and requested authorization to solicit bids once federal approvals are received 📄. Council discussion included: Councilmember Leone questioning if Filbert Stairs align with NMTPP transportation goals and suggesting other stair projects might be more suitable 📄. Councilmember Ford agreed, emphasizing disaster recovery aspects and wanting to discuss other stair repairs 📄. Leone also suggested reactivating the bike/ped committee for community feedback 📄 and emphasized coordination with other projects like the Phil Frank memorial near the Ice House 📄. City Manager Politzer noted coordination was underway 📄. Leone clarified that current projects do not include changes to Humboldt Avenue alignment 📄.
Motion
Motion by Councilmember Leone to accept the status reports on the Bridgeway Path, Ferry Landing and Gate 6 Road, and Bridgeway to Ferry Landing improvements, and to adopt the resolution authorizing the city engineer to advertise for construction bids for the Bridgeway to Ferry Landing improvements and the Filbert Stairs project. Seconded by Councilmember Ford. Motion passed 📄.
D
Award Contract for Construction of the Sausalito Yacht Harbor - Bay Street Bulkhead Replacement Project 📄
Director of Public Works Jonathon Goldman presented the item, detailing the bid process and recommending award to Ray's Construction of Pomona, CA, as the lowest responsive and responsible bidder at $4,221,248. 📄 The project budget requires a supplemental appropriation of $878,373, bringing the total to $5,078,373, which includes contingencies, lumber, construction management, and utility costs. 📄 Goldman explained the teaming agreement process to foster cooperation and potentially reduce costs. 📄 Councilmember Mike Kelly inquired about Ray's Construction's qualifications; Goldman noted their 23 years of heavy and marine construction experience, including work for local governments and Travis Air Force Base. 📄 Councilmember Jonathan Leone raised several concerns: questioning the need for an elevated boardwalk versus an at-grade walkway to save costs and avoid ADA issues, 📄 arguing that fire suppression costs should be the marina owner's responsibility, not the city's, 📄 and expressing broader concerns about project financing, cost-sharing, land ownership, and loss of city leverage in negotiations. 📄 City Manager Mary Wagner noted that fire suppression improvements were driven by fire department comments for the entire peninsula and that permitting compliance would need review if the boardwalk design changed. 📄 A representative from Ray's Construction expressed willingness to participate in teaming/partnering. 📄
Motion
Councilmember Mike Kelly moved to adopt a resolution finding the project categorically exempt from CEQA and awarding the contract for construction. 📄 The motion was seconded. 📄 The motion passed with Councilmember Jonathan Leone abstaining. 📄
Public Comment 1 1 In Favor
A
City Manager Information for Council 📄
City Manager Adam Politzer provided three brief updates: (1) Confirmed the strategic planning retreat is set for Friday, March 25th, as discussed at the previous council meeting 📄. (2) Announced a special city council meeting on St. Patrick's Day, March 17th at 4 p.m. at the Bay Model to swear in and meet the new police chief, Jennifer Tejada, followed by a reception until about 5:30 p.m. 📄. (3) Noted he will be attending the City Managers Conference in Monterey after the meeting, through Friday afternoon 📄. Mayor Mary Wagner and Councilmember Linda Pfeifer acknowledged the new police chief, with Pfeifer saying 'Thank you' 📄, 📄.
B
Mayor's Appointments of Councilmembers to Boards/Committees/Liaisons 📄
The item began with Mayor Herb Weiner announcing appointments: himself and Council Member Jonathan Leone to the legislative committee, and Council Member Linda Feiffer to another role 📄. Council Member Mike Kelly then introduced a motion to clarify the Housing Element Committee's status 📄. He proposed designating it as a task force with the sole purpose of assisting in preparing the draft Housing Element under the Community Development Department's direction, exempt from certain code sections (like 2.58) that govern ongoing committees 📄. The task force would have nine members: two council members (appointed by the mayor, who also appoints chair and vice chair), two planning commission members, and five citizens, and would dissolve once its work is complete 📄. Council Member Carolyn Ford sought clarification on membership count 📄, and Council Member Linda Pfeifer asked about the difference between a task force and an ad hoc committee 📄. Kelly explained it provides specificity under the code, avoiding term limits and ongoing responsibilities associated with regular committees 📄. Ford inquired about other major differences, and Kelly indicated none he was aware of 📄. The discussion was brief with no opposition noted.
Motion
Motion to direct staff to bring back a resolution clarifying the Housing Element Committee as a task force with nine members (two council members, two planning commission members, five citizens), appointed by the mayor, with the sole purpose of assisting in draft Housing Element preparation under Community Development Department direction, exempt from code sections like 2.58, and to be dissolved upon completion. Motion passed 📄.
C
Future Agenda Items 📄
Councilmember Linda Pfeifer requested two future agenda items: confirmation of the BAC economic study staying within current zoning designations, and transparency on MLK finance restructuring, which she learned about from a meeting with Charlie regarding pension liabilities and had questions and concerns 📄. Councilmember Carolyn Ford inquired about the timing of the BAC committee report presentation, wanting to meet with Rob Eiler before the council hears it 📄. City Manager Adam Politzer clarified that Rob Eiler is being invited to a council meeting to clarify the scope of his work and provide an update, with possible dates of February 15th or March 8th 📄. After discussion, consensus emerged to aim for March 8th to allow Councilmember Ford to meet with Eiler on February 17th 📄. Mike Kelly noted that March 8th aligns with Eiler's preferred timing from the BAC meeting 📄.
D
Councilmember Committee Reports 📄
Councilmember Jonathan Leone provided brief committee reports. He mentioned a vacancy on the Historic Landmarks Board (HLB) and suggested considering applicants from the Planning Commission pool to fill it, noting terms are ending in April/May 📄. He also reported on the Marin Energy Authority (MEA), stating they awarded landfill gas contracts for green energy, hired Don Weiss as director at a reasonable cost, and improved their financial focus, making it a more functional entity than six months prior 📄. Mayor Herb Weiner indicated he would soon request formal committee reports 📄.

Meeting Transcript

Time Speaker Text
00:00:32.89 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
00:00:32.90 Jonathan Leone Thank you.
00:00:32.94 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
00:00:33.04 Jonathan Leone Okay.
00:00:34.98 Unknown Okay.
00:00:35.55 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
00:00:42.89 Jonathan Leone Thank you.
00:00:42.91 Herb Weiner I'm kidding you.

Ready?

Excuse me, good evening.

And everybody, welcome to the Tuesday, February 1st, 2011.

meeting.

And at this time here, Well, that's okay.

Chairman, your excuse.

Go to your room. And so at this time here, I'd like to have a roll call, please.
00:01:11.95 Unknown Council member Pfeiffer? Here. Council member Leon?
00:01:15.97 Herb Weiner Here.
00:01:16.36 Carolyn Ford Thank you.
00:01:18.11 Unknown Councilmember Ford here.
00:01:19.53 Carolyn Ford here.
00:01:19.82 Herb Weiner Thank you.
00:01:19.88 Carolyn Ford Thank you.
00:01:21.00 Unknown Mayor Weiner.
00:01:22.60 Herb Weiner THE PRESIDENT.

Okay, Dr. Thornton, surely would you please lead us in the pledge?
00:01:36.62 Herb Weiner Pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
00:01:38.01 Linda Pfeifer flyer.

from the United States.

Thank you.

One nation.
00:01:44.98 Mary Wagner you I'm not.
00:01:51.96 Herb Weiner Thank you.

Thank you.

At this time here, I'd like to move the consent calendar up at this time here so it can be
00:02:06.58 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
00:02:08.82 Herb Weiner All right. I'm sorry.
00:02:10.09 Mary Wagner Mr. Mayor, just for clarification, you had no closed session items tonight, so there's no need to take public comment, obviously.
00:02:15.17 Jonathan Leone So, you
00:02:16.82 Herb Weiner Okay. All right.
00:02:18.27 Jonathan Leone Thank you.
00:02:19.93 Herb Weiner So we'll move the consent.
00:02:22.02 Jonathan Leone No, it's just a little bit of the same.
00:02:23.15 Herb Weiner Yeah.

Thank you.
00:02:25.90 Jonathan Leone Just stay with me.
00:02:29.02 Herb Weiner Okay, at this time here, there is no public approval of the agenda.
00:02:35.28 Jonathan Leone that this is
00:02:36.55 Herb Weiner Yes, I move the approval.
00:02:37.22 Jonathan Leone Thank you.
00:02:37.24 Linda Pfeifer Yes, I move it.
00:02:38.88 Jonathan Leone Amen.
00:02:39.06 Linda Pfeifer Yeah.
00:02:39.85 Jonathan Leone So.
00:02:40.02 Herb Weiner Aye. Opposed?
00:02:40.18 Linda Pfeifer Bye.
00:02:41.66 Jonathan Leone I'll make the second.

Thank you.
00:02:43.70 Herb Weiner Okay, now you can tell it's only my second month here.
00:02:47.28 Linda Pfeifer The President.
00:02:48.92 Herb Weiner .

And for all of you out there, you are on TV.
00:02:53.32 Jonathan Leone We do have a TV camera now in here to put these meetings on the Internet. So you're not being watched for your license plate out. We're not Timberon, so don't worry about that.
00:02:58.70 Herb Weiner You're not being watched for your license plate.
00:03:00.36 Linda Pfeifer Yeah.
00:03:00.49 Herb Weiner Bye.
00:03:00.53 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
00:03:00.56 Herb Weiner We're not sure.
00:03:01.05 Unknown Thank you.
00:03:01.08 Herb Weiner on.

And at this time here, it's kind of neat. We'll have some special presentations.

and the acknowledgement of those Sausalito Marin City School District students reaching the 900 Club. And with that, Thank you.

Deborah Bradley?
00:03:20.30 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
00:03:20.72 Herb Weiner Oh, Thank you.

David. Oh, I'm sorry.
00:03:29.97 Unknown Thank you.

take standardized tests on a variety of subjects. And students who achieve a combined score of 900 on the English, Language Arts, and Math portions of the test are welcomed into the 900 Club. Students who are being recognized for their achievement tonight are from Bayside Elementary, MLK Academy, and Willow Creek Academy in the Sausalito-Brinne City School District. Superintendent of the School District, Deborah Bradley, is here to explain the test further.
00:04:09.26 Deborah Bradley Thank you very much, but you did such an exemplary job. I don't know if there's much left to say. Before I make any comments, however, I would like to introduce the board members who were able to be here this evening. I would like to introduce Mr. Thomas Neumeier, who is President of the Board of Trustees for the Sausalito Marin City School District. Vice President Mr. Trotter is unable to be here this evening. Clerk of the board is Ms. Karen Benjamin.

And also joined with us this evening are Dr. Shirley Thornton and Mr. William Ziegler.
00:04:56.66 Deborah Bradley I will invite Ms. Carol Cooper up to introduce any representatives of the Willow Creek Board.
00:05:14.87 Carol Cooper It's my pleasure to introduce Andrew Boyd Goodrich of our board and Glenn Hayashi. And I believe those are our only two board members who are here this evening.
00:05:27.88 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
00:05:33.79 Deborah Bradley And in case you don't know, Ms. Cooper is head of school at Willow Creek Academy.
00:05:40.10 Herb Weiner Thank you.
00:05:40.11 Deborah Bradley you
00:05:40.28 Herb Weiner Thank you.
00:05:40.37 Deborah Bradley Thank you.
00:05:42.14 Herb Weiner Yeah, at this time here, Deborah, I'd like to really congratulate our young students for really making the city of Sausalito very, very proud for your efforts.

I wish I did as well as you. But I'm very happy to say that I am very proud of what you have achieved. And I'd like to hear from the other council members.
00:06:09.71 Linda Pfeifer Well, I just want to congratulate each of you.

It's a great effort and we're all very proud And just my heartfelt congratulations on this great accomplishment.
00:06:26.40 Carolyn Ford I will echo that and say congratulations to you all. I know it's a lot of hard work and it's something that we should reward and I'm very proud of you. And thank you for being here tonight.
00:06:44.74 Jonathan Leone Thank you all for coming first of all. Thank you for taking time out of your evenings to come. I think this is the fourth year now, the third year in the council chambers. The fourth, first year was the I happened to attend, last time I was at the Bay Model. And this is, I think, a celebration both of your hard work at all three schools as well as of 94965 as an entity in togetherness. And all three schools belong in this community, and Sausalito is a part with you in this zip code that we call 94965.

And your parents should be very proud of you. I'm sure they are. And for those who couldn't attend tonight, because I know it's also hard to get schedules to come, I know we'll pass on the certificates to them as well. And I want you all to know that, you know, we're trying to build this community together.

At least in my own personal opinion, Sausalito is not an island away from the other parts of 94965. We're all in this together. And your efforts at making your individual efforts better and your schools better are very much appreciated by this governmental entity. So thank you all for coming.
00:08:02.88 Deborah Bradley Thank you. Yes, it has been four years, if we include the Bay Model. And just to keep it in perspective, at one time, the state of California set the bar at 800 and thought that if a school or students could achieve 800, that would be something that would be a culminating activity in the eyes of the state as to how fabulous a school or a school district was. So for these students this evening to be recognized to have achieved 900 or higher is certainly that bar being raised significantly, and you're correct in your acknowledgment of their success.

That being said, if I might at this time make the introductions, we will go with the younger grades to the older grades, and the students may or may not be here. Some I know had conflicts with schedule and homework assignments. For third grade, Corey Lewis.
00:09:01.06 Linda Pfeifer It's the first time.
00:09:04.92 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
00:09:07.02 Deborah Bradley No, no, no, no.
00:09:07.22 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.

you Thank you.
00:09:08.98 Deborah Bradley Yeah.
00:09:09.41 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
00:09:10.24 Deborah Bradley Thank you.
00:09:10.31 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
00:09:10.73 Adam Politzer Dr. Bradley, if I can ask the counselor to come down and join you folks, that would be terrific.
00:09:10.75 Linda Pfeifer Yeah.
00:09:10.97 Herb Weiner Crack.
00:09:23.98 Deborah Bradley And Brenda Rodriguez Mazageros.
00:09:45.63 Deborah Bradley Grade four, Michael Baliserri.
00:09:56.63 Deborah Bradley Jacob Blum.
00:10:15.48 Deborah Bradley Mia Kruger.
00:10:24.25 Deborah Bradley Isabel Rivera.
00:10:48.08 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
00:10:48.65 Deborah Bradley Marcus Trotter.
00:10:56.86 Deborah Bradley Jeanie Spritz.
00:11:06.07 Deborah Bradley Sotel Sprit.
00:11:08.90 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
00:11:13.28 Deborah Bradley Grade five, Carla Kenyatta.
00:11:17.90 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
00:11:23.13 Deborah Bradley Mikhail Damesko.
00:11:39.87 Deborah Bradley Piper Gilmore.
00:11:41.05 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.

Thank you.

Thank you.

I'm sorry.

Thank you.

Woo!
00:11:58.40 Deborah Bradley Amir Modan.
00:12:17.60 Deborah Bradley Priscilla Navas.
00:12:19.12 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
00:12:23.66 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.

Thank you.

Bye.

Bye.

Thank you.

Thank you.
00:12:40.06 Deborah Bradley Ronnie Perea.
00:12:46.31 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
00:12:47.74 Deborah Bradley Great.

Carrie Clark.
00:13:07.06 Deborah Bradley Sophie Gilmore.
00:13:25.96 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
00:13:28.16 Deborah Bradley Mishbah Mamun.
00:13:56.98 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.

Bye.
00:13:59.04 Deborah Bradley River Mata.
00:14:14.60 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.

Thank you.

Bye.
00:14:23.07 Deborah Bradley Grade 7, Carly Alexander.
00:14:32.59 Deborah Bradley Gavin Boyd Goodrich.
00:14:53.92 Linda Pfeifer Yes.

you
00:14:55.64 Deborah Bradley Grade eight, Tu Dam.
00:15:07.16 Deborah Bradley Gabrielle Kraft.
00:15:10.42 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.

Thank you.

Thank you.
00:15:15.20 Deborah Bradley and Luca Osborne.
00:15:24.14 Deborah Bradley That concludes our awardees this evening.

Is someone?
00:15:28.16 Linda Pfeifer IT'S A LITTLE BIT.

Thank you.

Thank you.

Thank you.

Thank you.
00:15:31.43 Unknown This is for you.
00:15:34.08 Deborah Bradley Thank you.

you
00:15:41.45 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
00:15:54.73 Linda Pfeifer Aracanata.

Yeah.
00:16:25.90 Herb Weiner And that concludes that. And I get a feeling after you all leave, there won't be anybody left here. Thank you.
00:16:32.87 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
00:16:33.58 Herb Weiner But thank you very much for coming.
00:16:35.86 Linda Pfeifer Thank you very much. Thank you.
00:16:37.93 Carol Cooper Thank you.
00:16:38.86 Jonathan Leone Thank you.

.
00:16:40.84 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
00:16:41.17 Jonathan Leone Thank you all for coming.
00:16:46.98 Linda Pfeifer you
00:16:48.31 Herb Weiner Thank you.
00:16:48.33 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
00:16:53.19 Herb Weiner Okay, now...

Thank you.

Where is the public comment?
00:18:07.22 Herb Weiner Okay.

Let's now back to normal. At this time, are we ready, Deb? At this time here, take some public comments on items that are not on the agenda And I have two names at this time.

Amy Blakeney.

I know I didn't pronounce that right.
00:18:31.12 Amy Blakeney Thank you.

Hi, my name is Amy Blakeney and I'm a board member of FireSafe Marin, which is comprised pretty much of fire chiefs in Marin County, Caltrans, Parks Departments, and other various individuals that are interested. Thank you so much for letting me speak with you tonight. My concern is that I would like to talk to you about the Caltrans Corridor, our main artery to our county. Highway 101 is where citizens commute, tourists travel, and business look for locations to start companies.

After almost 75 years of neglect, our highway corridor looks old and in many sections is an enormous fire hazard.

In 2010, I made a request to Bijan Sartipi, Caltrans District 4 Director, for a highway beautification project using transportation enhancement funds.

The T program consists of regional and interregional improvement programs.

Marin's award for the 2010 Regional Tea Program was $1,003,000.

Those funds became available to the Transportation Authority of Marin.

in 2013 through 2015.

I was informed by TAM that funds always go for bike paths, and is never considered for highway beautification or fire safety.

That leaves the interregional program, which gets 25% of the T funds.

and is only available to state and federal agencies.

in 2010.

the City of Colosu and Glen, both on I-5, received funding.

My request to Mr. Sartipi.

was for Caltrans to apply on behalf of Marin County for a beautification project. The project request was to remove exotic invasive species and plant native vegetation, reducing the threat of wildfires and restoring our ecosystem.

I would like to request that the City of Sausalito submit a simple letter of support to Mr. Saratippe for Marin County Interregional Transportation Enhancement Project removing the exotic vegetation.

Support is needed from the City of Sausalito and other cities of Marin County for Mr. Suratippi to place Marin at the top of the request list. Secondly, I would like to assist the City of Sausalito in applying for a FireSafe Council matching fund grant.

for the restoration of the city's eight acre on.

eight acres off of Rodeo Drive.

The deadline for submission is April 1st, and if the city has an employee familiar with grants, it would assist the process.

Third, I would like to request the City of Sausseli to consider removing all eucalyptus and exotic vegetation from City on property.

government must lead by example, and we cannot expect... Oops, is my three minutes up?

The hook's over there, I see.

Yeah.

I don't know where I was here. Remove exotic vegetation from city-owned property. Government must leave by example. Finally, and fourth, I wish the city would start a dialogue with Golden Gate National Recreation Area about permanently removing all eucalyptus trees and non-natives from the eastern slopes bordering Sausalito and Marin City.

GGNRA recently thinned some stands, but in my opinion, is only a band-aid to a much bigger problem.

Sausalito is categorized as California's community at risk for firestorms.

Please place environmental restoration and fire protection at the top of your list this year. Thank you.
00:22:32.39 Herb Weiner Thank you. Next, John Flavin.
00:22:36.29 Jonathan Leone It's no shirt, no socks, no service here.
00:22:39.14 Herb Weiner Thank you.
00:22:39.18 Linda Pfeifer So you're...

I'm not.
00:22:41.59 John Flavin Sorry. If it's above 40 degrees, no size. This is a follow-on to last week's episode on pensions. I'm just curious if, and I know you can't respond to things that aren't on our agenda, so I asked maybe you could post it on the website somewhere what Bartlett's or Bartell's response was to the question of what the change would actually gross dollar change would be from 2011, 2012 to 2016, 2017. I think he gave it to you in percentages, but then said he was going to respond to you with actual gross numbers.
00:22:46.52 Herb Weiner Little woman here.
00:23:16.71 John Flavin When I did that calculation on the back of an envelope using his numbers from his exhibit, I came with an increase of almost a million dollars, and that's why I'm asking. I must be doing something wrong, but that's taking it from his exhibit.

The second request I have, the same area, is that there was a comment made that CalPERS buyout is $43 million if we were to try to buy our way out of CalPERS.

My questions are, Is that the gross amount?

or is that net of the actuarial value of assets? And then the other question is, does that also include the 7% markup from calipers? And if you could just put that on a website or something, I'm just curious, again, I've used my numbers, I mean, just rough calculations, and I come up with a net figure that's less than half of that 43 million. So I'm just trying to figure out where my calcs are wrong. Maybe I need a bigger envelope. I don't know. year, that's less than half of that 43 million. So I'm just trying to figure out where my counts are wrong. Maybe I need a bigger envelope. I don't know. Thanks.
00:24:19.13 Herb Weiner Maybe a bigger calculator.
00:24:21.14 John Flavin Thank you.
00:24:21.29 Linda Pfeifer laughter
00:24:21.68 John Flavin Thank you.
00:24:22.59 Herb Weiner Thank you, John.

Okay, any other comments from the public at this time? Okay, then moving on to the approval of the consent calendar.
00:24:36.54 Carolyn Ford I move that we approve the consent calendar.
00:24:39.78 Jonathan Leone I just have a point of clarification. Sure. Mary, what is the purpose? Why do we need outside counsel for items?
00:24:41.37 Herb Weiner Sure.
00:24:50.03 Jonathan Leone 4C for the Saucyde Boat Yard project.
00:24:54.14 Mary Wagner item 4c
00:24:55.58 Jonathan Leone Yeah, the way it's said in the
00:24:57.96 Mary Wagner That, yeah, if I can clarify.

Councilmember Leone.

The item before you is to approve a legal services agreement with Best Best and Krieger. We've been utilizing Linda Backman who is a partner with Best Fest and Krieger to provide special public contracting assistance.

An example was used in the staff report, which is she provided assistance on the Saucyut O'Yacht Harbor bid process. She also assisted us on the public safety building process. The reason for the contract is McDonough, Holland & Allen, her previous firm has disbanded and we'd like to continue to be able to utilize our services.
00:25:26.36 Jonathan Leone Thank you.
00:25:31.74 Jonathan Leone Right, I understand the last part. So it's more just in public contract bidding law observance of the complicated processes thereof that we're using her services.

monitor the legal aspects of this. That's just dealing with the contract, not with the legal agreement and or and illegal issues.
00:25:53.22 Mary Wagner She was not involved in the negotiations with Sausalito Yacht Harbor itself. It's the bid process and then the actual if there are questions that arise during the construction process on the the public work itself, we may utilize her services at that point.

Thank you.
00:26:12.61 Herb Weiner Okay, so on that consent calendar, any other?

All in favor? Aye. Aye. Opposed?
00:26:20.15 Linda Pfeifer All right.
00:26:23.50 Herb Weiner Second. Can I have a second, please? Thank you.

Hmm.

We don't have a permit.

Okay, thank you. The next item is the business items, and it's the housing element update status report from Lilly.
00:26:43.09 Unknown Good evening, Mayor and Councilmembers.

Yeah, I put it on the...
00:27:01.57 Unknown Thank you.
00:27:01.58 Linda Pfeifer It would be really hard for it to show up.
00:27:01.60 Unknown A really hard food to show up.
00:27:14.63 Unknown I think we're ready.
00:27:20.43 Unknown At the January 11th City Council meeting, the council received a status update on the housing element update effort and directed staff to return with a roadmap, which would include a revised work schedule for updating the housing element, in addition to more information on the first community workshop.

Last night at the January 31st HEC meeting, the HEC approved the roadmap workshop date, a workshop agenda, and facilitation and noticing options for that first community workshop.

Tonight's meeting will provide the council with HEC's recommended items for council endorsement this evening.
00:28:05.66 Unknown The first is the Roadmap, which is the HECC-approved revised work schedule, which provides specific dates and assigns responsibilities for the production of materials for the housing element update.

And you have a...

a copy of that roadmap in front of you provided to you as late mail.

And you can see at the top is listed the topic, the specific task, the date by which it's to be completed, and who is responsible for completing it in addition to the current status of that task.

You can see the first two items in the roadmap are the housing needs and housing constraints sections. And these chapters have been approved by the HECC last year.

The next item is the first public workshop. The workshop will be the first in a series of three workshops on the housing elements update and will be focused, the first one will be focused on an introduction to the housing element update and state mandated requirements.
00:29:12.28 Unknown Moving along in that roadmap, The next item is the site inventory. And the HUC was formerly proceeding with subcommittees to collect background data and then submit reports on various topic areas such as accessory dwelling units, live aboards, underdeveloped land and vacant land.

the responsibility for the collection and the inventory of the data And the report writing has been assigned to staff now, who will produce the technical background studies, submit them to HEC for review, and for their comment and subsequent revisions.

then a round of revisions will occur and the reports will be brought back to the HEC for review and approval.

The reports will then be formed into a completed inventory.

and analysis by staff. The completed inventory will then be forwarded to HEC for their review and their site visits to the various sites that are identified in the inventory and their comments. And then the document will be revised several times through the same process and then brought back to the HEC for final approval.
00:30:26.72 Unknown The last items, the first one here is the, we would conduct a second public workshop.

And this would be presenting the findings and recommendations from the HEC on the site inventory.

Next, the HEC would look at goals, policies, and programs. There'll be a similar process where the staff produces the document, distributes it to the HEC. The HEC reviews it, comments, gives it back to staff. Staff then incorporates the comments, gives it back to the HEC, HEC reviews, and eventually will hopefully approve the document.

then there will be a third public workshop on that goals, policies, and programs topic.

The final tasks will include an evaluation of the existing housing element, which is currently going on right now. We're in the middle of completing that.

And then finally, the environmental review.

Staff will then take all the approved documents, compile it into one final document, And the HEC will again review it, comment, and we'll come up with a final document which will be forwarded to the Planning Commission and the City Council for the initiation of their meetings on the final document.
00:31:47.46 Unknown The second item to discuss tonight is the first public workshop.

The workshop will be focused on.
00:31:52.95 Jonathan Leone Lily, do you want us to save our questions to the end or kind of ask you along the way?
00:31:56.49 Unknown However you'd like to get it.
00:31:58.45 Jonathan Leone It doesn't matter to you.
00:31:58.77 Unknown And I'll think to you then.
00:32:02.58 Jonathan Leone Would it make sense, instead of postponing the evaluation of the previous housing element, and I would include the 95 and then whatever it was, the 2005 or 2006 draft, to move that kind of up in sort of the initial
00:32:14.63 Mary Wagner six.
00:32:20.98 Jonathan Leone housing opportunities and site inventory discussions that either at the HEC or at the whatever level you staff feels appropriate to sort of flush out the programs that were in those that either worked or didn't work and then either add those or not add those into the other opportunities that I mean.
00:32:42.15 Unknown Sure, yeah, I'll clarify that. I kind of glossed over it. We're actually, staff produced an evaluation document in the June and August timeframe last year. The HEC took a look at it, formed a subcommittee to review it and provide comments and came up with an alternative draft
00:32:44.37 Jonathan Leone Yeah.
00:32:59.28 Unknown So the HECC right now, actually at the February 28th meeting, We'll have an opportunity to take a look at both of those drafts and review them and then select one for approval. So the HECC is taking a look at that document right now.

So we are looking at the 1995 housing element and evaluating it.
00:33:20.95 Jonathan Leone Right.

because I remember reading you wrote that a long time ago, that evaluation of the 95 one.
00:33:26.67 Unknown 90.
00:33:27.01 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
00:33:28.95 Jonathan Leone but incorporating some of those in the in the prior housing, because it looks like you're building kind of a, sections of the final draft of the document, right?
00:33:38.48 Mary Wagner Doc.
00:33:41.45 Jonathan Leone Um, Incorporating that in this earlier the housing opportunity section, kind of what's good in that, not necessarily what's bad, obviously, or what didn't work. Is that going to be part of what comes out of the next review of that?

Do you see what I'm saying? There's like 20 menu items in that.
00:33:58.33 Linda Pfeifer Right.

Right.
00:34:00.78 Jonathan Leone Housing element.

most of which were not considered to date.

in the three things that they put forward, the committee's put forward so far.

Is there going to be a review of those again to sort of consider putting them in these alternatives?
00:34:13.67 Unknown The review of the housing element is the current housing element. It's the 1995. I think you may be referring to the draft.
00:34:19.07 Jonathan Leone Right.

No, either, both of those. If there are good ideas in them, which were either dismissed or not considered because it just wasn't part of the prior process, when are those going to be reviewed and reconsidered.
00:34:33.73 Unknown Those should be reviewed when the HEC talks about the evaluation of the 1995 housing element. So that should happen this month, at the end of this month.
00:34:39.15 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
00:34:39.17 Jonathan Leone Okay.
00:34:39.77 Linda Pfeifer Yeah.
00:34:41.38 Unknown Thank you.
00:34:41.48 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.

Thank you.
00:34:41.60 Unknown Thank you.
00:34:41.61 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
00:34:41.63 Unknown Thank you.
00:34:45.36 Unknown Any other questions right now on the road map? I think we can have questions later too.

So the second topic area tonight is the workshop itself, the first workshop, and which will be an introduction to the housing element update to the community. The agenda approved by the HEC last night includes first presentation on Sausalito's existing housing and population conditions, which will include special needs groups and characteristics of the existing housing stock.

And then also a presentation on the constraints to construction of housing in Sausalito, which includes both governmental and non-governmental constraints.

Next, there would be a presentation on the housing element itself, what it is, and what is required by the state of jurisdictions in updating their housing elements.

And that would include the consequences of not updating the housing element.

Next there would be a brief overview of the new laws that have been passed since our housing element was last updated.

And finally, we would briefly present a summary of the data that has been gathered so far in each of the topic areas, and then provide the announcement that this is just one in a series of workshops, and there would be additional workshops on the housing element update.

And then finally, there would be a question and answer period.
00:36:15.03 Carolyn Ford Okay.
00:36:18.43 Unknown The use of a facilitator was also discussed at the HEC meeting last night. The benefits of using a facilitator for the workshop are that the facilitator would provide a neutral body.

for the workshop.

And if the services are found to be of high quality, A contact could be established and if other housing element-related needs were identified, such as a peer review of the final document or additional workshop facilitation or assistance with the state certification process.
00:36:50.99 Jonathan Leone to who's selecting the facilitator, this subcommittee.
00:36:53.61 Unknown This subcommittee?

Yeah, so the HECC decided last night to form a two-person subcommittee with Vice Chair Cox of the HECC and committee member Steve Flahive. The committee would work with staff to evaluate the candidate facilitators and then come together and select one facilitator for the workshop.
00:37:01.17 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
00:37:23.80 Unknown The HEC also authorized staff to provide noticing for the community workshop in these ways that are listed on this screen here, which includes publishing a flyer insert in the Marin scope.

a draft of that that was distributed to you.
00:37:42.78 Linda Pfeifer Yeah, we have that.
00:37:42.82 Unknown Yeah.
00:37:43.27 Unknown that.
00:37:45.50 Unknown And this would be printed on brightly colored paper and inserted into the marine scope.

Also, we could put those flyers at City Hall, put the notice on the city's website, create and distribute a press release packet for local community groups and local newspapers. You could also publish an article to the email distribution list and send a letter or the notice to those that have indicated they'd like to receive notification of housing element
00:38:20.33 Linda Pfeifer Amen.

Mary.
00:38:21.80 Herb Weiner Yes, you mentioned.
00:38:22.69 Linda Pfeifer So Lily, is it Correct, my memory is correct in that when we discussed this This says, we were going to change the term housing element to affordable housing because the concern was that people people would not know what the housing element meant.
00:38:43.18 Unknown Thank you.
00:38:43.92 Linda Pfeifer in the first paragraph.
00:38:44.83 Unknown My notes, and maybe correct me if I'm wrong, were that we were going to add, it said state-mandated housing requirements, and we were going to add four affordable housing. But we could have taken incorrect notes on that.
00:38:47.21 Linda Pfeifer where that
00:38:56.39 Linda Pfeifer Okay, maybe the committee can take a look at the final one.
00:38:58.38 Unknown Yes.

that's a final.
00:39:04.07 Unknown Thank you.
00:39:04.09 Jonathan Leone Thank you.
00:39:04.22 Unknown Thank you.

you
00:39:06.50 Jonathan Leone Thank you.
00:39:06.52 Unknown Thank you.
00:39:06.53 Jonathan Leone Thank you.
00:39:06.68 Unknown It's not just for.
00:39:07.56 Jonathan Leone The housing element is not just about affordable housing, though people may want to use it as a football for such. It's about all aspects of housing.
00:39:07.65 Unknown the housing element is not just the out of
00:39:14.48 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
00:39:14.67 Mike Kelly of housing.

you
00:39:15.76 Jonathan Leone Thank you.
00:39:15.78 Mike Kelly Thank you.
00:39:15.85 Jonathan Leone Yeah.
00:39:15.88 Linda Pfeifer Yeah, and I think that's why we didn't change the header, but the sense was that we needed to also mention that affordable housing was included in that, you know, for public awareness and community outreach.
00:39:16.03 Mike Kelly Thank you.
00:39:20.62 Jonathan Leone with you know.
00:39:21.87 Unknown Thank you.
00:39:29.62 Mike Kelly for public awareness and community outreach. Housing requirements for the city of Sausalito, including affordable housing.
00:39:36.49 Unknown That's fine. That's all right.
00:39:37.30 Unknown That's all right.
00:39:38.02 Mike Kelly Thank you.
00:39:38.06 Unknown Thank you.

That okay?
00:39:38.97 Mike Kelly not necessarily a driver.
00:39:38.98 Unknown Thank you.
00:39:46.70 Carolyn Ford Okay.
00:39:48.38 Unknown So I have that change noted on the flyer.
00:39:54.49 Unknown So with that, staff recommends that the City Council endorse the following HECC recommendations, which are, one, the approval of the work schedule, which is that roadmap, and then, two, approval of the February 26th community workshop, which includes the endorsement of the date, the agenda, the selection and use of a facilitator, and the noticing options.

And that concludes our stock report this evening. And we're available for any questions.
00:40:22.00 Carolyn Ford Okay.
00:40:24.61 Jonathan Leone So just to clarify, because the way this is phrased is somewhat confusing. And I'm sorry we didn't get it ahead of time. So I'm just looking at it as you.

Passed it out.

So the fact that some of these say Completed.

does not prevent an analysis of other housing opportunities or us.

other elements in here that have been previously drafted. Is that correct?
00:40:50.52 Unknown That's definitely correct. The HEC will have an opportunity at the end when everything comes together to take a look at everything that they've approved will be compiled into one document. They'll have several opportunities to take a look at it as one full document, make revisions, comments, changes,
00:41:09.74 Jonathan Leone So my suggestion would be, given the length of time that's passed and the, I think the somewhat bumpy road that this committee has been on that maybe we break these into sections that come back to the council before, rather wait until the whole document is submitted as a whole in terms of the committee's suggestions on certain parts of it.

Not so much the statistics, but those are what they are, even though people have fought to change those as well, but the opportunity strategies and things like that.
00:41:57.61 Mike Kelly Perhaps as each staff completes a draft of each section, it brings it back to the council. Thank you.
00:42:02.91 Unknown Yeah, that's correct.
00:42:07.59 Unknown Any other questions, I think?
00:42:11.84 Herb Weiner Thank you. This time here any public comments on this item?
00:42:12.50 Unknown Thank you.
00:42:19.14 Herb Weiner Okay, bring it back up here.
00:42:24.44 Herb Weiner Thank you.
00:42:24.46 Jonathan Leone One other thing, sorry I mixed in a comment before rather than just a question.
00:42:25.03 Herb Weiner Thank you.

and just
00:42:28.27 Unknown Question.
00:42:28.86 Herb Weiner is.
00:42:31.72 Jonathan Leone I would just have the staff select the facilitator. I mean, it's just, you know, it's going to, let's decouple the politicization of this and leave it as a staff-run project and rather than couple it to, I mean, it's great to have people do a lot of hard work, but it's a presentation by the city, right? So let's, that would be my suggestion is to have the city staff validate the facilitators.
00:42:47.93 John Flavin Uh,
00:42:48.15 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
00:42:48.17 Mary Wagner Thank you.
00:42:57.69 Herb Weiner Any other comments?
00:43:01.60 Carolyn Ford Well, I...
00:43:02.19 Herb Weiner Council Member Ford.
00:43:04.57 Carolyn Ford Thank you, Mr. Mayor. I think we have... It would be nice to have a joint staff and the committee make that decision because we appoint our residents for a reason.

And I just feel that residents should have a say in who they want to work with as well as staff. I mean, it seems to me that both are on the committee.

have input from both. That's all I'll say.
00:43:41.14 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
00:43:41.17 Carolyn Ford Thank you.
00:43:41.21 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
00:43:41.24 Carolyn Ford .
00:43:41.33 Linda Pfeifer you
00:43:41.80 Mike Kelly I'm going to ask Jeremy to come up for a second. But it was my view last night that what this was was more a help to staff to try to interview a couple of people and staff would eventually make the decision.

you That's what I understood.
00:43:55.37 Herb Weiner Council Member Fiverr, go ahead.
00:43:56.85 Linda Pfeifer My understanding, Mike, was that at staff's recommendation actually, Uh...

Bye.

the concept was to form a subcommittee to help select the facilitator, and it was going to be a joint venture between staff and the subcommittee. And this was that staff's recommendation. So I don't see this as politicizing it. I think it's called, I think it's empowering the committee to be a part of planning the first workshop. And so I, you know, I think it's important to have a resident voice in that process.
00:44:35.12 Mike Kelly I don't have a problem with the selection as long as with the facilitation of selecting the facilitator, if you will. But I still think that the end decision lies with staff to make the decision.
00:44:36.15 Mary Wagner of the soul.
00:44:51.73 Linda Pfeifer Well, as we discussed it yesterday, we can go back and listen to it, but my recollection of the conversation was that this was going to be a joint process, and that was the purpose of forming the subcommittee, was to have the committee's voice as part of that.
00:45:15.32 Herb Weiner When do we get the interpretation from the...
00:45:17.50 Mike Kelly Let me just say a similar thing. The precedent for this would be, for example, in the selection of police chief. There was a citizen's committee, interviewed the police chief, gave recommendations, comments, et cetera, but the final decision lies with the city and city manager. I think that should be always the case. It's money here we're talking about and other issues. So that's my view.
00:45:18.53 Herb Weiner one of the...
00:45:41.61 Unknown The way we discussed it last night was for there to be essentially a three-position subcommittee, Lily and I did not go over the PowerPoint presentation, and so the staff suggestion last night was for there to be two of the HEC members on that subcommittee and committee members, Cox and Flahy, step forward, and so the understanding at the staff level was that the staff and those two committee members would work together, evaluate the resumes of the potential facilitators and select one with basically a consensus model. I think we can come together. We have several well-qualified candidates, and it's an opportunity for us to bring their skills to Sausalito in facilitating the workshop on a topic that is of great community interest.
00:46:27.01 Mary Wagner Thank you.
00:46:27.04 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
00:46:27.16 Mary Wagner Thank you.
00:46:46.41 Mike Kelly Wasn't the feeling also that we wanted to use somebody from outside the community so that there would be no
00:46:46.80 Unknown THE FAMILY.
00:46:52.42 Unknown There's certainly, that certainly is a component of it. You know, there's pros and cons on that basis of do we want to place the priority on a facilitator that knows the dynamics of Sausalito or are we looking more for someone who is coming and knows housing elements and is getting their introduction granted to Sausalito. Part of the workshop itself would be, you know, certainly they know housing elements well, but they would be getting input on the community concerns as part of that, and that might provide us future benefits if we, the HECC and the Council decide that at a future point we need some additional assistance on finalizing and the certification process for our housing elements.
00:47:09.68 Jonathan Leone Thank you.
00:47:39.36 Linda Pfeifer And it was my recollection that the HEC committee discussed the pros and cons of using someone who was local versus using someone outside and there were equal weights on both points.
00:48:00.22 Herb Weiner I think last, by the way, I might add, there was one name brought up. I think that they've handled something like 50 of these, some number like that, on housing. And I think they were batting 50-0. That impressed me.
00:48:17.60 Linda Pfeifer Yeah.

Thank you.

Mr. Moon.
00:48:20.44 Carolyn Ford Mr. Mayor, this seems like Council's getting too far into this. It seems like the staff... Excuse me. I have the floor, I think.
00:48:27.27 Linda Pfeifer Sure.
00:48:27.66 Unknown because
00:48:28.03 Herb Weiner The staff, and the staff.

Thank you.

Excuse me, I have... It's okay.

I think.

Yes, you do.
00:48:35.27 Carolyn Ford I think what we need to do is let staff and our resident members who are on the committee work this out. And it sounds like you already have. And I think we can be confident that with both we'll get the right person. So, and I'm assuming you have several good candidates, so why don't we let the appointees we, the council has appointed, take their responsibility along with staff and move forward.

I move that we accept the report that we're given tonight with the direction of the...

with the work plan and with the The direction that the heck is is headed I second
00:49:31.36 Jonathan Leone I'll call the vote on that. Please just call. Let's take the vote.
00:49:37.57 Mike Kelly Wait a minute, let's discuss.
00:49:39.31 Jonathan Leone Thank you.
00:49:40.12 Unknown Yeah, typically you just want to...
00:49:40.68 Mike Kelly I need some discussion before I vote.

you
00:49:45.03 Jonathan Leone Thank you.
00:49:45.12 Mike Kelly So,
00:49:45.27 Jonathan Leone Thank you.
00:49:45.40 Mike Kelly Thank you.
00:49:45.42 Jonathan Leone Thank you.
00:49:45.45 Mike Kelly Thank you.
00:49:45.49 Jonathan Leone Well, I think, okay, so maybe just...

losing patience with this whole process.

I think what needs to be clear is this, in my mind, is that this Constitution, this committee, This is the last test in my mind of this Constitution, of this committee.

if it goes and wanders off again, This community, in my mind, should be reconstituted with a whole new batch of people.

Okay, or just...

set aside and gone through the planning commission and then through the Council.

I don't want to play any more games, any more politics, any more what the residents, citizens, that's subjective. No one from Sausalito can come in and represent the whole town. So having a facilitator that is representative of Sausalito is good luck in finding that. And the fact that Sausalito is a unique place, but these issues are not unique to Sausalito. So what you need is someone who has some familiarity with these issues to help the community adapt those ideas to Sausalito Tosasio's vision of itself, which is again a subjective thing.

Um, And I don't want to get into another situation where we've played kid gloves with the last 18 months of letting this committee basically push around the staff.

So what the which no other committee or board or commission does.

So the Next, so in my mind, if you want to just take this, and again, we always hear two different recountings of what happens at these meetings.

So.

unless we're going to transcribe every meeting I tend to not believe what either one of you say about it because they're always polar opposites.

Thank you.

nothing against you as individuals, but they seem to be, it's two people who walk out of the same meeting with different points of view if they walked in with different points of view.

So what...

I think that I'm just tired of dancing around this, as I said at the last meeting, and I think I made it in the paper, but this is the last go around. If this gets politicized, if it becomes another attempt to Game the system.

if it becomes another attempt to then to me, then we should just take that record off the turntable and put another one
00:52:03.81 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
00:52:05.80 Jonathan Leone Not that I don't appreciate people's hard work, but at some point, you've got to get the train back on the tracks.
00:52:12.54 Herb Weiner Any of them?

Council Member Kelly? Well... Vice Mayor Kelly.
00:52:14.87 Mike Kelly Thank you.

and did that right too. Sorry. Last night was a reconstituted meeting. And I personally, as my feelings about this have been well known, that I wanted staff to drive this train and I wanted the committee to facilitate the staff's preparation of the various elements that need to go into this thing and to, you know, to the extent they can give advice and so on. But at the end of the day, it is my view that staff makes the decisions about this and brings it to the Council with the committee's dissent or
00:52:17.50 Herb Weiner to All right.
00:53:02.01 Mike Kelly I'm sorry.

support, one of the two. And the buck stops here, not anyplace else. And we all have been reading the newspaper, I assume, and see that Novato has had a particular problem in the way that they chose to go after this and other jurisdictions.

Um, have been successful or not successful depending upon how well they organized this.

It's a very technical thing that we're involved in.

of of technical information that has to go in here and has to be vetted by the state and we're in constant contact with the state as we go through it.

it far surpasses my experience and I believe everybody else on that committee except for staff.

who is trained and understands, and Jeremy in particular understands this process.

So it's, in my view, staff driven. Staff, the final decisions about what to present to the Council, which could include positive and positive.

two points of view is fine, but it's staff's decision, and I hold staff responsible for providing an element that we can finally get certified, or at least bring to the council for its decision about whether to certify it or not, have it certified.

If anything deviates from that, I'm not for it. If we all can agree on that, I'm for it.

Thank you.
00:54:28.28 Linda Pfeifer Thank you, Mayor. I just want to say how proud I am of this committee and this committee's efforts and the dedication of these residents to...
00:54:28.30 Mike Kelly Yeah.
00:54:43.10 Linda Pfeifer spend their time and come to these meetings. I think we've only had one member who had to resign because she couldn't make the meetings. I'm sure as council member knows, you know, each of us knows how hard it is you know, when we make a commitment you know, to an organization, to a committee, to attend those meetings, and achieve those goals. I am proud of Steph.

I am proud of the committee and I am proud of what we have achieved.

We are not gaming the system, we are talking to the system. We drove to Sacramento, we drove to Oakland and talked to the Association of Bay Area Governments We, uh, We have, you know, done a lot of outreach and, you know, I am so proud of the accomplishments of this committee. And I'm proud of the way they have helped staff and the way that we have moved forward on something that frankly has been stuck, it's been stuck for two decades. And we're seeing the schedule ahead of us. We're seeing a successful outcome and we're going to get there.
00:55:57.13 Carolyn Ford Okay.

Thank you.
00:55:59.35 Carolyn Ford Well, just briefly, because I've already said what I wanted to say. But I do think we should empower the people that we put on these committees. It appears to me that they have done a great job in working towards their goals. And I think that staff is working with them right now. So let's let it move forward with...
00:55:59.76 Carolyn Ford Well, Thank you.
00:56:02.97 Mary Wagner Right.
00:56:03.40 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
00:56:03.42 Mary Wagner I'm sorry.
00:56:24.43 Carolyn Ford Thank you.

both staff and residents being empowered.
00:56:29.98 Herb Weiner So on your motion, are you saying also that the staff will have the final say in what comes up to us?
00:56:41.42 Carolyn Ford What I'm saying is let staff and the two residents who have been appointed proceed with choosing the consultant and let them bring it forward. If there is disagreement, I would think that would be worked out in the committee, if not, Let them bring it forward.
00:57:02.91 Herb Weiner Yeah, but the motion...
00:57:04.61 Carolyn Ford MS. Either way, they can bring it forward.

Yeah.
00:57:07.06 Herb Weiner Council Member Leon.
00:57:09.03 Jonathan Leone I don't think so. This process keeps churning, okay? And let's be clear. This was an issue in the election, and there were polar opposite points of view.

and the the people who are representing the more midstream, mainstream point of view on this, or sitting up here?

Okay, so let's not pretend that that issue wasn't fully vetted and that wasn't one of the things how it determined how people voted.

So you can pretend that all you want.

but, If one of the selectors is one of the people who was putting forward the idea of trying to use Marin City's housing, public housing, as part of our public housing allocation, And things like that.

That's why the process needs to be clear, that the staff makes the end decision for all these things.

And the staff has to mind their P's and Q's and make their decisions wisely that certainly there are residents on these committees They're providing input from the community.

And if the staff is going way out on a limb on the other side, that's certainly not what the purpose of the committee is.

I haven't seen that through this whole 18 months. So I've seen the opposite.
00:58:21.95 Unknown Thank you.
00:58:22.20 Mike Kelly I'm going to say that.
00:58:22.25 Jonathan Leone Thank you.

I'll advise you.
00:58:24.78 Mike Kelly I just have one thing to say about The ultimate decision, as you know, is us.
00:58:30.54 Linda Pfeifer All right.
00:58:30.88 Mike Kelly It's not staff or anybody else. So, but what I don't want to see is a dysfunctional committee staff situation where we have to make every little decision along the way.
00:58:39.95 Carolyn Ford Which is what it turned into. It's what it turned into.
00:58:40.41 Mike Kelly It's what it turned into. It's what it turned into. Right. So then... So I couldn't... I mean, I understand that we involve the citizens in this and we want their input, but at the end of the day, staff makes the decisions and brings it to the council. And that's how I view it.
00:58:42.94 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
00:58:55.04 Mary Wagner Thank you.
00:58:55.11 Carolyn Ford brings it to the couch.
00:58:55.90 Mary Wagner Thank you.
00:58:56.03 Herb Weiner Thank you.
00:58:59.44 Herb Weiner Thank you.
00:59:01.42 Carolyn Ford Well, I think...
00:59:03.49 Herb Weiner Well, you have a motion, you could either change it or just continue with that and see how that goes.

I really do thank you.

Honestly, I kind of agree that we should Let the staff still be the driving train and they come up to us.
00:59:28.72 Linda Pfeifer Mr. Mayor, I think your microphone is off.
00:59:31.36 Carolyn Ford Sorry.
00:59:31.66 Linda Pfeifer Okay.
00:59:31.69 Carolyn Ford Thank you.
00:59:31.71 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
00:59:31.74 Carolyn Ford Thank you.

Well, let me just say this. I think that staff will bring it to us. I think that having the committee's input is what staff will be portraying. I think that that's where we are.

So, if I may.
00:59:55.25 Herb Weiner I think we're there. Look, I have a feeling that
00:59:57.53 Carolyn Ford I have a feeling.
00:59:58.81 Linda Pfeifer Yeah.
01:00:00.08 Herb Weiner If we can agree on this, I think that committee can move forward and be constructive. If all of them and everybody understands that it's still staff driven taken the input from the committee and the residents and then make the presentation to the council.

So I think your wording is very close. I think if we just include that the staff does have... Don't forget, the staff is going to make a recommendation to us. Yes, exactly. So why don't we just move it along and go with that understanding of the staff.
01:00:38.11 Carolyn Ford Yes, exactly.
01:00:47.51 Herb Weiner And I think we can move forward and you have your direction.
01:00:51.58 Jonathan Leone Let's just be clear. So the staff will solicit opinions from this subcommittee, but at the end the staff will make the recommendation to the council.
01:00:52.98 Herb Weiner Okay.
01:01:00.20 Carolyn Ford with the two members or whoever the housing element committee has selected helping staff with that. I want to.
01:01:01.96 Jonathan Leone Yeah.
01:01:02.26 Herb Weiner Bye.
01:01:07.15 Herb Weiner I wanted staff. Excuse me, but yet the ultimate decision will be made by staff.

What's wrong? And they should...
01:01:14.24 Linda Pfeifer Yes.

Yeah. Well, which one?
01:01:15.95 Linda Pfeifer and
01:01:17.03 Linda Pfeifer I just...
01:01:18.51 Herb Weiner They should really.
01:01:19.41 Linda Pfeifer Your microphone is off again.
01:01:19.49 Herb Weiner Yeah.

Thank you.

Maybe on purpose. I think we're spinning our wheels on a lot of little technical things. Let me just interrupt for a second. Council Member Leon, go ahead.
01:01:23.72 Linda Pfeifer I know.
01:01:28.72 Linda Pfeifer I'm not.
01:01:28.99 Jonathan Leone Thank you.
01:01:29.02 Linda Pfeifer I agree.

Thank you.
01:01:30.81 Jonathan Leone on the ladder, little technical things? Let me just interrupt for a second. Councilmember Leon, go ahead. In 2002, when the zoning ordinance was rewritten, which was a two-year process, No one from that committee, which was made up of the, which was basically the planning commission, and Mary and a special consultant and a few people who would come in on different issues. No one came to the council and made presentations. There wasn't a need to be out in front and get, and I don't think anyone felt the need to do that. But for some reason you keep putting this committee forward like it is like some beacon.

you know, and that it needs to get out and it needs to lead presentations and it needs to present to city council and it needs to make decisions about the facilitator. The council picked the, I think even the city manager picked the facilitator for that process.

I just don't get it. It sounds like tea party kind of stuff that when you kind of call about this, the residents, it's like you speak for everyone. You speak for no one.

Let the people speak for themselves.
01:02:38.40 Unknown I...
01:02:38.68 Jonathan Leone Okay, and it's a lack of understanding of how government works efficiently.

because this is churned for 18 months. We were done in 18 months. You have not put a document on the table in 18 months.
01:02:46.11 Herb Weiner months
01:02:52.96 Herb Weiner Okay. Well, just for the sake, but look, Yes, sir.
01:02:59.07 Jonathan Leone I call a spade a spade, and this scenario has been a circus.
01:02:59.56 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
01:02:59.59 Herb Weiner Thank you.
01:02:59.68 Linda Pfeifer I'm calling.
01:03:00.15 Herb Weiner you
01:03:00.20 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
01:03:00.32 Herb Weiner Yeah.
01:03:03.88 Herb Weiner Look, the body up here is to give direction, and I think...
01:03:05.31 Jonathan Leone Yeah.

And thank you.
01:03:06.07 Mike Kelly Thank you.
01:03:06.11 Jonathan Leone Thank you.
01:03:06.26 Mike Kelly Thank you.
01:03:06.29 Jonathan Leone you
01:03:06.44 Mike Kelly THE END OF THE END OF THE
01:03:12.79 Mike Kelly I was at the committee meeting last night. Linda was at the committee meeting last night.

It was conducted efficiently with good purpose. The presentations were made by staff. There was agreement, consensus, and so on.

So I think with this little tiny modification that we just kind of rest with the staff to make ultimate decisions, we can go on and nobody's ever going to care about that because everybody's working.
01:03:32.23 Jonathan Leone BEFORE THE PALACY.

because everybody's working on it.

Thank you.

We counter motion, we provide the actions as presented by staff in terms of the timeline, the workshops, agenda.

Thank you.

We'll fly or complete with the changes that were recommended with a caveat that the staff makes a recommendation about Who the facilitator is. Yeah.
01:03:55.26 Herb Weiner Do I have a second?
01:03:56.58 Mike Kelly you
01:03:56.65 Herb Weiner So,
01:03:56.73 Mike Kelly Thank you.
01:03:56.76 Jonathan Leone Thank you.
01:03:57.71 Linda Pfeifer I would like to discuss this.

I just need to say that the process that was put forth at the Housing Element Committee was recommended by staff. It was presented as a consensus where these two committee members volunteered their time to work with staff and help staff. And, you know, frankly, I think that whether it was...

I feel like this council is micromanaging a process that doesn't need to be, you know,...... micromanage this for 18 months and nothing good came of it.
01:04:29.06 Jonathan Leone You have micromanage this for 15 months.
01:04:32.68 Herb Weiner Thank you.
01:04:32.76 Jonathan Leone to the next day.
01:04:32.83 Herb Weiner Let's put a stop to this. The time is...
01:04:34.03 Jonathan Leone So, I'm going to call the vote. There is no, in Robert and Rosenberg's rules, there's no, you can call the vote and the deal has to be discussed. He can vote on the second one first.
01:04:38.83 Herb Weiner In Rosenberg's rules, there's no...

I was second.

You vote on the second one first. Okay, thank you. All right, Debbie, so we'll vote on the second motion first. And that was seconded by...
01:04:56.69 Unknown Councilman or Vice Mayor Kelly.
01:04:56.89 Herb Weiner Vice Mayor Kelly.
01:04:58.14 Mike Kelly Thank you.

Thank you.
01:04:58.73 Unknown Thank you.
01:04:58.75 Mike Kelly Yes.
01:04:59.02 Unknown No, you seconded. I'm just saying. Oh, I seconded it. I don't know. I'm just kidding. There's only words here. Council Member Pfeiffer. No.
01:05:00.77 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
01:05:00.79 Mike Kelly Yes.
01:05:01.03 Linda Pfeifer I'm just trying to get this checkered. I don't know. I'm just kidding. Yeah.
01:05:05.02 Mike Kelly I'm sorry, I'm sorry.

Thank you.
01:05:10.24 Unknown Councilmember Leone.
01:05:11.82 Mike Kelly Yes.
01:05:13.39 Unknown Councilmember Kelley.
01:05:14.47 Mike Kelly Yes.
01:05:16.48 Unknown Councilmember Ford.
01:05:18.49 Carolyn Ford No, I think we need to go with what the committee recommended. Just the vote, please. And stop politicizing this. Mayor?
01:05:23.13 Unknown JUST.
01:05:23.33 Linda Pfeifer and stop politicizing this. Mayor Weiner.
01:05:27.03 Unknown Mayor Weiner.
01:05:27.79 Carolyn Ford Thank you.
01:05:29.90 Herb Weiner Yes.

This is, after watching it last night, and I could not comment because there were two other members, this is going to move forward, and I'm going to make sure it does, and I think that...

I vote yes. Okay, let's move on.
01:05:53.83 Herb Weiner Thank you. Okay, next item on our agenda.
01:05:57.15 Linda Pfeifer you Thank you.
01:05:59.58 Herb Weiner Good night, Chris.

Thank you.
01:06:02.79 Linda Pfeifer Oh my...
01:06:04.09 Herb Weiner Okay, next item is the Street Repair List 2011 Fiscal Year Preliminary Work Plan, including storm drain repairs and Todd.
01:06:04.10 Linda Pfeifer Oh, Thank you.
01:06:15.31 Herb Weiner He was here.

here.
01:06:17.69 Jonathan Leone Thank you.
01:06:18.70 Herb Weiner .
01:06:19.53 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
01:06:19.95 Herb Weiner Thank you.
01:06:20.96 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
01:06:20.98 Herb Weiner you
01:06:21.03 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
01:06:46.36 Jonathon Goldman Good evening.

I'm before you today to give you an update on the 2011 street repair program. I think back in November you authorized a contract with CSG to assist in the preparation of the work program and the contracts for this coming year's street program. between November and now. CSG took what the work that was done last year, updated our pavement management system, ran some reports, and then fact-checked it against conditions on the street, and then presented a rough cut plan, which we then further refined based a more intimate knowledge of the conditions of the streets and some other factors. So today I wanted to present to you the list that is suggested. We want to run this by you before we develop the plans and specs in great detail. The numbers generated for this total, the budget amount, but to get to that amount, we had to identify some streets as ad alternates.
01:07:41.35 Unknown Oh.
01:08:19.39 Jonathon Goldman Um, both in the overlay of asphalt streets and the overlay of concrete streets. There was a Another change that we added as well, way back in April of last year, we had the rains of 2009, 2010 caused some problems.

on Sausalito Boulevard as well as Sagali Lane.

between April and now we've developed several alternatives. All of them seem to break the budget. So the most realistic solution we believe is to do a re-profiling of Sausalito Boulevard via pavement work and driveway modifications, taking that work from a drainage program more into a street repair program. So we wanted to present that to you and point that out and see how that flies with you all.
01:09:28.58 Unknown Thank you.
01:09:33.89 Jonathon Goldman getting direction if you feel otherwise.

Also, since with the current year, We've had some problems up at F-Type. We have a minor slip out, and we want to repair that with this coming program. So we've got a small slope repair project.
01:09:44.02 Mary Wagner Thank you.
01:09:44.03 Linda Pfeifer My.
01:09:44.29 Mary Wagner Thank you.
01:09:53.48 Jonathon Goldman Thank you.

Thank you.
01:09:53.54 John Flavin Thank you.
01:09:54.87 Jonathon Goldman on Ebtide.

So this is a map showing the, there's a, before you on the podium I have given you the list as well as examples, the, the,
01:10:02.94 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.

Thank you.
01:10:12.59 Jonathon Goldman the map is coded to be, I think, read as...

Thank you.

Red is dig-outs, orange is slurry-seals, and blue is overlays, streets. Graphically, this is the full picture of what's proposed for the current year.
01:10:34.19 Jonathan Leone To clarify two things.
01:10:35.93 Jonathon Goldman Thanks.
01:10:35.98 Jonathan Leone you
01:10:36.25 Jonathon Goldman Thank you.
01:10:36.67 Jonathan Leone Thank you.
01:10:36.69 Jonathon Goldman What is it to go?

A dig out is essentially a very structural patch. Okay, patches.
01:10:47.10 Jonathan Leone patches, like what was done on Atwood. On Locust
01:10:49.75 Jonathon Goldman Or Atwood. On Locust Street, on Second Street.
01:10:51.79 Jonathan Leone Or second, going up to the lower part of Nevada. Okay. And what does add alternate mean?
01:10:53.85 Jonathon Goldman Thank you.
01:11:02.81 Jonathon Goldman The full list before you totaled $738,000. So staff reviewed the overlay streets, weighed the feedback that we've gotten through various channels, and put in priority on it, and more or less drew the line to get us down to the budget amount of $509,000.

Um...

Thank you.

We are going to advance the design work and the estimating work on the project. We'll come back to you to show you the refined project before we go out to advertise, make what we expect to be some minor adjustments. At that point, we'll decide whether or not to embed those segments within the project or not. But as a very planning level estimating, we think these are the priorities as we've been getting them.
01:12:14.32 Carolyn Ford So Todd, if I might, you'll bring those back around budgeting time so we know what we're looking at, the design and the costs?
01:12:22.17 Jonathon Goldman WE'RE LOOKING AT THAT.

We hope to bring this back hopefully in March so that we can go out to advertise with the current construction season.
01:12:29.73 Carolyn Ford Thank you.
01:12:34.12 Carolyn Ford Perfect. Thank you.
01:12:34.83 Jonathon Goldman Thank you.

with the I wanted to point out also one of the overlay streets, San Carlos.
01:12:48.24 Jonathon Goldman Thank you.

uh...

everybody knows that. It's pretty rough, pretty bad, but it also has a fairly a sad-shaped sewer, so we're going to try to coordinate, as we did with Johnson in 2010, pavement work and sewer repair. That was the only street that we identified that had severe sewer problems as well as severe pavement problems.
01:13:22.36 Jonathan Leone So in the cases like B is an alternate here, which is dropped off last year's 2010 list, I thought that sinkhole thing was a sewer problem or is that a storm drain problem?

I'm not sure.
01:13:33.59 Unknown Yeah.
01:13:33.81 Jonathan Leone Thank you.

And so the general question is, In these estimates that you have, it would not include the subsurface repairs that may go on. Not on B Street.
01:13:42.77 Jonathon Goldman That may go on. Not on Beasts.

Yeah, the numbers. The anything here doesn't have the same.
01:13:46.53 Jonathan Leone The numbers. Anything here doesn't have the sewer repair in it. Correct, budget wise. And that would come out of the sewer fund or the sewer budget.
01:13:49.87 Jonathon Goldman Correct.
01:13:53.40 Jonathon Goldman Thank you.
01:13:55.03 Jonathan Leone Yes.

and Okay. Sorry, Todd, I didn't interrupt you there.
01:14:03.10 Jonathon Goldman Thank you.

Thank you.

It's hard to say. I hope it's somewhat self-explanatory.
01:14:13.36 Jonathan Leone Thank you.

Oh, go back because those are beautiful. Todd, you did an excellent job with the college.

Do you want it for the benefit of the council so it sinks in? What's the benefit of slurry seal? And is it an effective paving methodology?
01:14:28.50 Jonathon Goldman Slurry seal is a surface treatment that is done on roads of generally moderately good condition. The pavement management system utilizes a ranking from 0 to 100. Slurry seal is typically used on something between a 45 and a 65. And what it does, it does two things. It seals any of the micro cracks that are forming, as well as occasionally just the surface wear between tires and the pavement will diminish its abrasive characteristics. So on steep slopes and even on the freeways, to keep the surface condition away, it's a very cost-effective treatment generally. What it does, it extends a life between five and seven years. You know, the extension of a life for an overlay is generally considered about 20 years. That's not to say it's going to last 20 years without any sort of maintenance. It's starting anywhere from 8 to 12. You have to start doing preventative maintenance to keep that going. But streets that are in the moderate condition are treated as slurry seal, and that allows the city and all communities that do pavement maintenance to extend the life and get the maximum efficiencies from their limited resources.

And before you go,
01:16:12.97 Jonathan Leone I'm just trying to get my act together here. Before you go out to bid, and maybe you've already done this, so have you, given the problems we have with the sewer funding from the state, is there, will some of these just drop off if you're going to try and start them, you know, in May or whatever after the rainy season?

because we don't have that funding in place to do the subservice.
01:16:43.70 Jonathon Goldman I'll have to get back to you on that when we've got the plans more developed.
01:16:49.02 Jonathan Leone But the way the bid will function is even if you bid it all out, there will be a way to peel projects off if we can't do the sewer repairs underneath and substitute other things.
01:16:58.03 Jonathon Goldman That's the expectation, yes.

Yeah, the street repairs are generally quite scalable. I'm just trying to watch your game.
01:17:09.03 Jonathan Leone Thank you.
01:17:09.30 Jonathon Goldman Thank you.
01:17:09.40 Jonathan Leone And is this a good enough size to get some good interest, like we've had problems at some point getting
01:17:17.23 Jonathon Goldman Well, I think it's a fair amount. Clearly, the bigger the project, the more appealing it is to the medium and larger size firms. But this is a good amount. We'll see how it goes. But we had such success and such popular demand for the work, given how long it had been, seeing if we can repeat that effort this year.
01:17:47.98 Jonathan Leone One last question, if I may.

For Harbor Drive and Marine Shipway and these sections because you're not doing the whole run of it, it appears.

Does the city own all of those sections of these streets?
01:18:05.04 Jonathon Goldman Thank you.

Marin Shipway, yes. Everything else is generally known public right of way.

What was the last name? No. It's public. Public right of play. There are easements, but no. Not easements.
01:18:16.63 Jonathan Leone No.

It's public right away.
01:18:23.73 Jonathon Goldman the they go back generally to what was mapped back in the 1880s. So we have generally the strongest ownership we have.
01:18:34.70 Mike Kelly I'm sure if I tell you, I think I'll describe the reasons.
01:18:38.89 Jonathon Goldman No.
01:18:39.70 Jonathan Leone So I would say, absence of the obligation, I would suggest removing those streets where responsibility for, whether it's for this or the sewer program. And go to, as you were trying to do with the sewer program in the marinship, go to the property owners.

have that same discussion about their privately owned portions.
01:19:07.69 Jonathon Goldman Every street on this list is public. It's not an easement. It's a roadway right of way.
01:19:17.35 Jonathan Leone So Marinship Way from Harbor Drive south. Just to the depth of Molly Stones. So where that parcel ends. Yep. And that is a dedicated city street. Yes. And Harbor Drive from Bridgeway, I don't know where Road 3 is, but.
01:19:21.23 Jonathon Goldman So...
01:19:26.48 Jonathon Goldman Yeah.

Yes.
01:19:34.17 Jonathon Goldman Road 3 is right opposite the ICC. And more or less the road into Joe Lemon's
01:19:42.14 Jonathan Leone Okay.
01:19:42.17 Jonathon Goldman Okay.

Yeah.
01:19:42.96 Jonathan Leone And that then Clipper is past that and the other property. Correct. All right. So that's where that would end. So there's no private claims to these particular segments? No. And we've confirmed that? Yes.
01:19:46.79 Jonathon Goldman Thank you.
01:19:53.48 Linda Pfeifer you know.
01:19:58.17 Herb Weiner Um...

.

On Third Street, have they dug up, are they planning to do any more digging up there before we can kind of get this back to being a road?
01:20:12.26 Unknown I, I, you can ask, Jonathan may, Jonathan Leon, Councilmember Leon may be able to answer that better than I, but I've been in. That's because the city's making me dig it up. Oh, good.
01:20:14.03 Jonathon Goldman Thank you.
01:20:14.13 Herb Weiner Thank you.
01:20:14.18 Jonathon Goldman Thank you.
01:20:14.38 Herb Weiner Bye.
01:20:14.62 Jonathon Goldman Thank you.
01:20:16.41 Herb Weiner Council member Real may be able to answer that better
01:20:18.97 Linda Pfeifer Yeah.
01:20:19.02 Jonathon Goldman but I've been in a very good time.
01:20:20.04 Jonathan Leone because the city's making me
01:20:21.35 Jonathon Goldman There's a private utility undergrounding project going on. The main line is done. I don't – Council Member Leon may know better whether or not the electrical laterals are in.
01:20:24.97 Linda Pfeifer Yeah.
01:20:25.15 Unknown .

private.
01:20:34.16 Herb Weiner No, yeah.
01:20:51.32 Jonathon Goldman Okay, okay, yeah.
01:20:54.16 Unknown Thank you.
01:20:54.19 Linda Pfeifer And...
01:20:54.24 Unknown Yeah.
01:20:56.84 Jonathon Goldman the project manager on that is working with the various property owners to get the last distances resolved.

and then PG&E and AT&T and Comcast can come in and pull their conductors. But I haven't been given a recent update on that from either the contractor or
01:21:21.29 Mary Wagner is.
01:21:23.52 Jonathon Goldman the project manager. They've had some challenges though.
01:21:28.48 Herb Weiner Any other questions up here? This time here, any... Thank you, Todd. Any comments from the public at this time?

Okay.
01:21:41.31 Jonathan Leone you Thank you.

Todd, with the slope repair, where do we usually take – I know we – is that on the MLK property, or is that just in the right-of-way, you know, compared to what was up against the – what other condo association? Is one eptide –
01:21:57.22 Unknown Thank you.
01:22:00.97 Jonathan Leone Yeah. Whoa, whoa, too many things. Is it right by the dog park?
01:22:03.08 Jonathon Goldman Is it right by the dog park?
01:22:04.63 Herb Weiner Boy, Jonathan, I knew I gave you that for a reason.
01:22:05.03 Jonathon Goldman I don't know.

You know how a Lima kind of goes from a two-lane street to almost a one-lane street and wraps around?
01:22:08.22 Unknown Uh,
01:22:15.41 Linda Pfeifer Yeah.

Thank you.
01:22:16.04 Jonathon Goldman Right as it transitions back to a two-lane street, this little area from Ebtide to Bridgeway, the very, very top, it started to wash out.
01:22:16.09 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
01:22:29.45 Herb Weiner Yeah, you can see that. Right at the very top, right in front of the Ebtide department house. You have the one Ebtides on the right and then you have the complex.
01:22:32.91 Jonathon Goldman going to be.
01:22:42.29 Jonathan Leone So it's then?
01:22:43.76 Herb Weiner What did that talk?
01:22:45.40 Jonathan Leone So it's not any, it's not on, it's actually somewhere stuck. It's up in that complex. It's not down on the table.
01:22:51.22 Herb Weiner Thank you.
01:22:51.24 Jonathon Goldman Thank you.
01:22:51.25 Herb Weiner No, it's before.
01:22:51.96 Jonathon Goldman Right.
01:22:52.18 Herb Weiner Thank you.
01:22:52.22 Jonathon Goldman Thank you.

It's even outside of the
01:22:53.92 Jonathan Leone I'm not sure.
01:22:53.94 Jonathon Goldman Yeah, it's before it. Essentially, it's a...
01:22:53.99 Herb Weiner Yeah, it's before it.
01:22:56.96 Jonathan Leone Oh, it's next to, I forget who owns that. Yeah. It's that apartment. That apartment complex up there. Yeah. There's a single family.
01:23:00.11 Herb Weiner It's up on Ebtide. That apartment.
01:23:02.27 Jonathon Goldman complex.
01:23:02.73 Herb Weiner Thank you.
01:23:02.81 Jonathon Goldman There's a single family home. You know, when you come in to Bridgeway, there's that. Okay.
01:23:08.72 Jonathan Leone Thank you.

So in the past, I know for the MLK obviously we took that from the, we found funds in the MLK budget to do that slide repair or slope repair.

But generally, has it come out of the street repair program to do sort of slope or maintenance, even if it wasn't directly related to street repairs.
01:23:27.67 Jonathon Goldman Well, I think it's a case-by-case situation. In this particular case, the part that is moving provides the structural support to the roadway base, and it's within the public right-of-way. As far as we can tell, it's not...
01:23:43.52 Mary Wagner Thank you.
01:23:47.28 Jonathon Goldman Thank you.

It's just we don't know the full cause.
01:23:51.67 Jonathan Leone Thank you.
01:23:51.70 Jonathon Goldman Thank you.
01:23:51.78 Jonathan Leone Thank you.
01:23:51.80 Jonathon Goldman Thank you.
01:23:51.85 Jonathan Leone There's no other capital fund that could fund this, that rather than take it out of street repair.
01:23:59.45 Jonathon Goldman We can come back and explore that. For now, we're suggesting that we use the street repair fund. Clearly, as we get into the design aspects and learn more, we'll revisit that. Okay. Okay. Sorry. Thanks, Todd. Thank you.
01:24:03.01 Jonathan Leone or suggesting.
01:24:14.58 Herb Weiner Okay.
01:24:16.09 Jonathan Leone Thank you.
01:24:16.15 Jonathon Goldman Thank you.
01:24:16.62 Herb Weiner Anyone else? I have a motion accepting this repair list. Oh, I did say from the public.
01:24:22.68 Jonathan Leone Can I ask you?

Thank you.

Thank you.
01:24:25.77 Herb Weiner Can I get a minute?
01:24:26.89 Jonathan Leone Thank you.

Thank you.

Thank you.
01:24:27.31 Herb Weiner Yeah.
01:24:27.53 Jonathan Leone Thank you.
01:24:27.58 Herb Weiner as
01:24:27.59 Jonathan Leone Can I ask you to somewhat bifurcate this and just have to accept the repair list and just split off the street in front of my house as a separate thing so I can abstain on that particular portion because I actually keep trying to have this removed from the list even though my neighbors complain.
01:24:31.12 Mary Wagner I'm going to go.
01:24:31.14 Unknown I remember.
01:24:46.14 Mike Kelly Well.

Thank you.
01:24:49.38 Unknown Well, I live on South Street, and I notice South Street is on this.
01:24:53.21 Mike Kelly Thank you.

everything in all.
01:24:54.04 Linda Pfeifer It's a bird inside.
01:24:56.40 Herb Weiner The President.
01:24:56.53 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.

Well, you're not on the phone.
01:24:59.37 Mike Kelly Thank you.
01:24:59.42 Jonathan Leone Well, you're not on the list. You're not on the list.
01:24:59.98 Mike Kelly You're not on the list. You're not on the list. Okay. So why don't I make a motion that we accept the 2009-2010 fiscal year street repair list plan, accepting, it should be 2010-11, shouldn't it?
01:25:03.15 Jonathan Leone Thank you.
01:25:16.45 Linda Pfeifer Mm-hmm.
01:25:16.77 Mike Kelly and accepting the streets on South Street and Third Street, for which the two council members have recused themselves.
01:25:30.74 Herb Weiner I second. Okay. All in favor? Aye. Opposed?
01:25:31.08 Mike Kelly I see.
01:25:31.30 Carolyn Ford Thank you.
01:25:31.35 Mike Kelly Thank you.
01:25:31.47 Carolyn Ford Thank you.
01:25:31.67 Mike Kelly Thank you.

Thank you.
01:25:34.57 Carolyn Ford THE FAMILY.
01:25:34.74 Mike Kelly Thank you.

Now, same motion with 3rd Street and South Street being the receptive streets.
01:25:43.30 Herb Weiner Thank you.
01:25:43.75 Mike Kelly Thank you.
01:25:44.04 Herb Weiner Thank you.

Certainly.

Mary.
01:25:49.15 Mary Wagner That's fine. Just to note for the record that Council Member Leon and Council Member Pfeiffer recuse themselves of participation in the second part of the vote and then the three remaining Council Members.
01:25:53.45 Herb Weiner participation in the second.
01:25:54.62 Carolyn Ford Thank you.
01:25:55.24 Linda Pfeifer That's right.

Yeah.
01:25:56.22 Herb Weiner We remain in council members.
01:25:57.32 Linda Pfeifer Okay.
01:25:57.72 Herb Weiner Bye.

There's a second. All in favor? Aye. Opposed? So carried. Okay. Thank you, Todd. But you might as well stay there because you're up again.
01:25:59.77 Mary Wagner Thank you.
01:25:59.80 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
01:25:59.81 Mary Wagner Thank you.
01:25:59.85 Linda Pfeifer Bye.
01:25:59.87 Mary Wagner Thank you.
01:25:59.97 Linda Pfeifer Bye.
01:26:00.20 Carolyn Ford Thank you.
01:26:09.40 Herb Weiner He's writing for punishment. Okay, non-motorized transportation pilot program project status update.
01:26:22.68 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
01:26:26.93 Linda Pfeifer Well, that's.
01:26:31.17 Carolyn Ford Well, that's, I have the one from Gate 6 Road too.
01:26:34.98 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
01:26:35.03 Unknown Thank you.
01:26:35.34 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
01:26:35.40 Unknown That's this.
01:26:35.61 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
01:26:36.69 Carolyn Ford Oh, we're not discussing that tonight though, right?
01:26:39.74 Unknown Only grief, only has a status.
01:26:41.90 Carolyn Ford Oh, okay. All right, great. Yes.
01:26:43.94 Unknown Right.

Right.

Yes.

Thank you.
01:26:46.05 Carolyn Ford Thank you.
01:26:46.09 Unknown Thank you.
01:26:48.40 Carolyn Ford Okay.

Thank you.
01:26:49.23 Jonathon Goldman I just distributed the draft Gate 6 Road to Ferry Landing Path Plan slash feasibility study, which is one of the NNTPP projects that I'll provide status briefing on. And that one kind of kicks off.
01:26:50.03 Carolyn Ford I don't know.

Right.
01:26:56.23 Unknown Thank you.

Thank you.
01:27:10.88 Jonathon Goldman The city's been advancing three projects for several years.
01:27:19.25 Jonathan Leone Can I ask a point of clarification on the prior stats report?
01:27:23.84 Carolyn Ford Thank you.
01:27:24.04 Unknown FAST.

Thank you.

Thank you.

Thank you.
01:27:26.15 Jonathan Leone Maybe it's in here. Where do you talk about the tradeoff of Saugly Lane?

The $40,000 versus the $150,000, $120,000 alternative. Was that in the previous item or this one? Is that an either-or thing to fix those? Didn't you want guidance on that from us, or did you make a recommendation and we just went with your recommendation, just to clarification?
01:27:38.60 Mary Wagner Is that a joke?
01:27:46.40 Jonathon Goldman We embedded the repair of Sausalito Boulevard drainage. By resloping the street and the driveways. Correct. Sagali Lane, we will come back to you now that we've got some direction with regard to budget. We really had a severe resource limitation. This improves it tremendously.
01:27:53.81 Jonathan Leone Resloping the street and the driveway. Correct.
01:28:16.69 Jonathon Goldman Thank you.
01:28:16.74 Jonathan Leone Will you just keep those?
01:28:17.92 Jonathon Goldman Thank you.
01:28:17.97 Jonathan Leone folks on that lane up today. Sure. Sorry. Thank you.
01:28:22.88 Jonathon Goldman Thank you for the clarification.
01:28:24.05 Herb Weiner Thank you for the clarification.
01:28:24.94 Jonathon Goldman Thank you.

Thank you.
01:28:25.14 Herb Weiner Thank you.
01:28:25.28 Jonathan Leone Thank you.
01:28:25.30 Jonathon Goldman I wanted to give you an update of the non-motorized transportation pilot program projects that we're advancing.

The city received a funds for three projects in late 2007, and we've been working on advancing them since 2008. We had three projects. One is called, has had several names, the Bridgeway Path Plan, the Gate 6 Road to Ferry Landing Path Plan, and the report in front of you is the Ferry Landing to Gate 6 Road Feasibility Study. What it's supposed to, it's intended to do is scope a project for off-street bicycle and pedestrian facilities.

generally along Bridgeway, but not necessarily within all of Bridgeway. So we've been working with the...

a steering committee and interested residents to guide the development to provide input at various stages. I think we provided you an update in the early fall of last year pre-preparation of this and the feedback that we got from the last council meeting as well as from the steering committee and enabled us to finish this draft. It was presented in a publicly noticed workshop on November 16th. Our consultant provided the attendees at which there were about 20 and surprisingly about half were new faces.

Yeah, half were familiar faces, but half were new. About a 40-minute presentation was done to walk through the report. Questions were provided and answered. We announced that this is a draft public document. We encouraged them to take copies. We had several copies available for distribution review. They were given 30 days to comment. And we got six formal comments, and then we got one or two. towards the end, the Waldo Point groups weighed in and they were able to get together a thoughtful response about the plan within the deadline.
01:31:02.77 Mary Wagner Thank you.
01:31:02.82 Unknown Thank you.
01:31:03.23 Mary Wagner Thank you.
01:31:04.21 Unknown the
01:31:04.98 Mary Wagner Thank you.
01:31:18.15 Adam Politzer Thank you.
01:31:21.37 Jonathon Goldman Their main point was they wanted to be kept in the loop if we go into a project development stage. So...

The consultant currently has prepared draft responses to those comments, and some minor revisions are being made to this report. We hope to bring that back to you next meeting to go into it in detail and to get your support for it. And perhaps we're nearing the end of the project for that, and some action will be requested. So for those who, I only had four copies of the report available, it's available on our website under I think available reports. It's roughly a 90-page document, but it's available and has been for roughly 60 days. So that hopefully brings you up to date on the PATH plan project. The second project that we did was the
01:32:25.86 Mary Wagner Thank you.

Thank you.

Thank you.

Thank you.
01:32:39.82 Jonathon Goldman Ferry Landing to Bridgeway Improvement Project.

The council lasts.

weighed in on this project in November of 2009 when a budget augmentation was requested to enable the consultant to finish the design work. The plans were finished in mid-January, and between January and December, staff, between doing all the other service demands and working with a consultant. We finished the specifications in mid-December and submitted them to Caltrans for funding and for environmental review. I had a meeting with Caltrans last week reviewing the documents that were submitted. And some minor revisions are being made. They didn't provide me any feedback that was substantive, mostly a minor restructuring because what was presented didn't fit the format that they need for their processes. Apparently, I learned between the start of this non-mortarized transportation pilot program project, and now Caltrans was enabled by the FHWA to review and basically do the environmental review in-house. I guess in the past they pushed it out to FHWA staff and had various mixed results, So they're trying very hard to streamline the review process. The staff I'm currently working on are revising those documents. I hope I'll be submitting them as soon as I can get them done.

And they thought once a project is completed, it would be about a month turnaround. So I'm hopeful that they can get funding authorized in the springtime. I think the report said late February.

Um, We want to be sensitive to what goes on down there we don't want to have major construction going on during the summer time. So we'll see how it goes as far as whether we get to construction in the spring or whether we defer this construction until after September.
01:35:14.97 Jonathon Goldman Thank you.

That updates you, I hope, on the...

improvement project. Finally, there's the Sausalito Stairs project. We had two sites for this project. One was a rather controversial site up at Prospect and between Prospect and Sausalito Boulevard that after much deliberation you authorize us to stop development on that. We did that a while ago now.

However, there's always been support for the other site, which is called the Filbert Stairs. And staff has had numerous meetings with kind of the 200 or 300 foot radius people on how to best rehab these stairs. We explored, we learned that the current stairs is not within the city easements, so we had to explore whether or not we move them six feet over into the easement or whether we acquire easements. And then there was an issue of whether we continue. The stairs kind of go mid-slope, and then it goes into a driveway, and people take the driveway up to Casnell, which has a public pedestrian easement. There were some suggestions to explore just taking it all the way up. And the consensus was stairs, improved stairs was greatly desired and the sooner the better. There was unfortunately not enough support to change the route. So we've been working with the consultant to craft easement languages, and the council did authorize us in the past to execute easement agreements with the property owners. We've got signed agreements from the three affected property owners. We've got one technical glitch. One signature wasn't notarized, so we'll be working with them to notarize that.

Then the environmental documents were submitted to that, to Caltrans recently. They've given us some feedback for some minor revisions, and we await. There was a biological study that they have to send out to an internal group for review. That's probably the most challenging step that still has to be done. I don't know what the timing is for that. I'll be, I've informed them how much we would like to get these projects going, and they're sensitive to that from my understanding. And surprisingly, the staff is alert and energetic and raring to go. It's really quite the surprise from the typical Caltrans staff that I saw. I was very pleased.

So there were two, you know,
01:38:35.97 Unknown Thank you.
01:38:36.78 Jonathon Goldman the The non-Nordered transportation pilot program is part of the Safety Loo Federal Transportation Fund, and that fund technically was supposed to expire in September 30th of 2009, but because the Congress has been busy with what arguably is more important things, they have not yet come up with a new transportation bill. Instead, that they've been extending safety loop with continuing resolutions. And every time they do that, the pot of resources for the non-motorized grow. And back in November, we gave you a asked for your support to submit two proposals to go after some of these new resources. We submitted those proposals and we got some feedback that they need to be a little more detailed. So we're working with Parisi and Associates to refine the cost estimates and the work scope. We hope to have those to them in February.

And, um.

We're not sure what the county will do with those additional resources. They've been quite, Silent.

with us on that point. Jonathan may be able to share more on that particular point. But we're doing what we think is necessary that we can
01:39:59.94 Mary Wagner Thank you.
01:40:11.11 Unknown Thank you.
01:40:11.51 Jonathon Goldman address some longstanding community concerns. So that kind of summarizes the status. I did want to take this opportunity to ask, we don't know when the federal authorizations will occur.

But we're asking that you authorize us to go out for bid when those authorizations come, thereby saving anywhere from a week to a month of time to deliver the projects. So tonight there's a resolution attached to this report that kind of accepts the report and makes some determinations and authorizes us to submit those for bidding. And with that, the staff concludes this report.

Any questions at this time?
01:41:08.50 Linda Pfeifer So Todd, we met earlier today, just with respect to this.

And I just had a question for clarification because I remember you had come.

before the council of you know, before and said that you needed these funds Um...

And because if you didn't use them, then you can't do it.

we would lose them.

And so I was wondering what had changed because, you know, we haven't lost them.
01:41:45.24 Jonathon Goldman No, what's changed is the absence of a new transportation bill. The fact that that's been pushed out to, you know, as yet undisclosed date, we've been fortunate that we've been able to keep these projects alive. I discussed this with Caltrans and they did not indicate that as the county has, that we might lose these funds. I think we've got the documents. We're making good faith to meet the process that have to be done. We'll have to see.
01:42:31.74 Carolyn Ford Mr. Mayor, I have one question. So Todd, what you are asking us to approve is the work from Bridgeway to the ferry landing, right?
01:42:34.70 Jonathon Goldman Thank you.
01:42:34.80 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
01:42:34.95 Jonathon Goldman Thank you.
01:42:43.17 Carolyn Ford That project, am I? No.
01:42:45.19 Jonathon Goldman No. What I'm asking you to do is adopt a resolution that authorizes or actually a motion No, it's a resolution. I'm sorry.

authorizing us to solicit bids for these projects once we've gotten our uh, federal authorization in hand.
01:43:06.56 Carolyn Ford So these projects are the Alexander Avenue, the south end of town and the stairs?
01:43:12.43 Jonathon Goldman Thank you.

The ferry landing to Bridgeway improvements, more or less the sidewalk widenings on Anchor Street and Bay.
01:43:12.52 Carolyn Ford Thank you.
01:43:19.31 Carolyn Ford Okay.
01:43:19.35 Jonathon Goldman Thank you.

Thank you.

and the stair improvements at Philbert.
01:43:23.25 Carolyn Ford Okay, great. Then I just wanted to confirm that the Sausalito, that the Bridgeway to Ferry is the work, and a lot of it involves ADA work, on Bay Street and Anchor Street, right? Those are the only two streets affected, right? It's been a while since I looked at that. Yes.
01:43:37.78 Jonathon Goldman Yes.
01:43:41.96 Jonathon Goldman Yes. Okay. We do nip at the corners of Humboldt, which is where most of the buses stand and entrances to lot one and lot three and lot two as well. We're tweaking the corners a little bit, adding some planting areas and repositioning an inlet
01:43:51.41 Mary Wagner Thank you.
01:43:51.44 Carolyn Ford Mm-hmm.
01:43:51.90 Mary Wagner Right.
01:44:05.96 Carolyn Ford Thank you.

Thank you.
01:44:10.02 Jonathan Leone Yes, a quick one. Todd, what...
01:44:11.04 Jonathon Goldman Thank you.
01:44:12.98 Jonathan Leone What are the alternatives that you're proposing for the outside of Philbert that's an existing project in terms of what you're putting in for these new round of safety lube projects?

What were the alternatives that you presented to the Caltrans or the county?
01:44:32.03 Jonathon Goldman The Stair at Valley, specifically. Just that one. Yeah.

That one specifically, I think we framed it fairly broadly to allow us to narrow down the kind of gives us some opportunity to explore South Street Stairs and other locations. But there's also been, Jonathan's been coordinating with Dorothy Gibson and another group with regard to emergency access.
01:45:08.09 Jonathan Leone Right, so that was going to be my point, is that two things. One, the whole program is about getting people to walk to work, transportation, which the Valley Street stairs serve nothing of that regard. They serve in access to the beach. They're not a primary access route for any
01:45:18.94 Mary Wagner Thank you.
01:45:25.19 Jonathan Leone So any residences. So I don't know how that would make the requirement of the non-motorized transportation component of it because it's more an amenity than it is a transportation feeder.

And also, you've got sewer lines and storm drains underneath those stairs that may end up being a bigger bite than just kind of replacing some wood steps.

I would think you'd have a better shot at A, the funds, and B, having a more project and get your arms around cost-wise if there was a different locale to and I'm all for doing what we had. We had a whole litany of projects that Dorothy had recommended as far as stair projects rather than, and I don't even think this was one of them.
01:46:08.37 Mary Wagner We had a whole litany of projects.
01:46:15.59 Jonathan Leone in terms of the fire roots and all that other component of it.

I think that This one, though, it's a great amenity to the city.

There may be ones that are either more cost effective in terms if you looked at the whole project rather than just the and or.
01:46:33.07 Mary Wagner and or
01:46:34.34 Jonathan Leone would actually fit the goals of the one Motorized Transportation Pilot Program rather than just our desire to repair the steps.
01:46:35.93 Mary Wagner Mm-hmm.

Bye.

I was transferred.
01:46:42.90 Jonathan Leone Thank you.
01:46:42.91 Jonathon Goldman Point noted.

Thank you.
01:46:44.03 Herb Weiner Thank you.

Council Member Ford.
01:46:46.59 Carolyn Ford I agree with Councilmember Leon and there are, I think we should be looking at this in terms of disaster recovery, which I think you mentioned in your report.

But there are the South Street stairs, there's the Sagali, there's the lower cable roadway. All of these need repairs, and I walk those every day. So I would like to meet with you and discuss that as well before we move forward. So I will call you on it. Okay. Thank you.
01:47:12.17 Jonathan Leone with you.

Bye.

and decided.
01:47:13.44 Mary Wagner Bye.
01:47:17.00 Jonathan Leone I should call you.

you, Anna.

Okay.

Thank you.

But I would use the, in my opinion, it may be best to use whatever your remnant of the tech, whatever that thing is. Do we still have the bike ped motorized committee membership of some kind?
01:47:32.05 Jonathon Goldman they're all a
01:47:35.19 Jonathan Leone around, I think. I mean, he's died.
01:47:35.21 Jonathon Goldman I think...
01:47:36.93 Unknown I'm not cutting it. Yeah.
01:47:39.26 Jonathon Goldman Thank you.

Thank you.

Thank you.
01:47:40.09 Jonathan Leone Maybe you can, I mean it's great to get all the feedback you can but maybe, you know, to get some, as people like to say, community feedback, that might be a good way.
01:47:40.74 Jonathon Goldman Thank you.
01:47:46.51 Jonathon Goldman Yeah.

that.
01:47:49.72 Jonathan Leone Thank you.
01:47:49.85 Jonathon Goldman The members of the last constituted group, a lot of them have changed status. There were former council members who are now not on the council.

former planning commissioners that have moved out. But when that group was authorized, the authorization I think sunsetted, I'm not sure if it was this last June 30th, possibly.
01:48:12.33 Jonathan Leone Maybe the mayor can do something about that for you, if you remind him.
01:48:12.38 Jonathon Goldman Maybe the mayor can do something.
01:48:18.12 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
01:48:18.22 Jonathan Leone Thank you.
01:48:20.48 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
01:48:21.61 Carolyn Ford Okay.
01:48:22.14 Jonathan Leone Thank you.
01:48:22.15 Carolyn Ford Thank you.
01:48:22.19 Jonathan Leone And two other quick things. Todd. Todd, and two other quick things on this one. So on the... On the...
01:48:22.44 Carolyn Ford I'm not sure.

Cut.
01:48:32.63 Jonathan Leone current projects and the new ones if you select them to get the safety loop funds. Certainly, you know, get McClashen's office, get them in the loop and we can, you know, staff and city manager and the council can lobby them because they can lobby and in turn lobby the county for us for those funds and we should.

Your improvements on, what's the second one here, next to the Historical Society building near the Ice House, what street is that?
01:49:07.84 Herb Weiner That is paid.
01:49:09.35 Jonathan Leone That's Bay. You've tied in your changes with their proposed changes on that corner for this.

Phil Frank Honorarium.
01:49:18.55 Herb Weiner That's near the ice house. That's on the other side of the outside.
01:49:20.44 Jonathan Leone outside of the outside. The President of the United States, I hope they've met.
01:49:24.05 Herb Weiner That's north of the ice house.
01:49:26.80 Jonathan Leone But as you get to the design stage, you'll get there.
01:49:26.94 Herb Weiner Thank you.
01:49:26.97 Adam Politzer but as you get to the design stage.
01:49:29.10 Herb Weiner Yeah.

All right. OK.
01:49:30.68 Jonathan Leone Thank you.
01:49:30.87 Herb Weiner Okay.
01:49:31.12 Adam Politzer Thank you.
01:49:31.16 Jonathan Leone Thank you.
01:49:31.17 Adam Politzer And Mr. Mayor, if I can just comment on that quickly because I think it's important. The South Dakota Foundation has met with staff. The Community Development Director has created a flow of the permitting process for them. They're going to be meeting in the next couple of weeks with, and they don't know this yet, but the City Attorney, the Public Works Director, and the community development director to make sure that we all understand what the process is. Then they'll come to the council, which is the owner of the
01:49:49.15 Linda Pfeifer Yeah.
01:49:49.28 Mary Wagner Thank you.
01:49:51.41 Linda Pfeifer the attorney,
01:50:01.56 Adam Politzer to make sure that the council is in support of of their ideas. I think they've talked to several members of the council in their I think they plan to meet with everybody if they have not out there at that site to talk about the proposed improvement that they'd like to recommend.

we understand that there's an opportunity to do the work once and the coordination I think is what Councilmember Leone's point is there and staff is aware of that and working with them as I know the Public Works Director. Yeah, I mean, I'm expressing
01:50:30.99 Jonathan Leone Yeah, I mean, I'm not expressing a point of view one way or the other, but it just seemed there was an opportunity to kind of double, to extend funds both ways, because there's some ADA challenges on that corner there because of the curb cut height and all that other stuff. So if we're getting that efficiency, that's all I was wondering about.

And one last one. There is no, so on Humboldt, with what we're approving tonight, there is no, the vision that was outlined in terms of the bus alignment and all the other stuff, none of that is, nothing on Humboldt is being...
01:50:50.96 Mary Wagner There is.
01:51:00.74 Herb Weiner Thank you.
01:51:02.23 Jonathan Leone Thank you.
01:51:02.25 Herb Weiner being touched.
01:51:03.02 Jonathan Leone Now, nor is there any change of alignment that may have been proposed in that study in terms of where the sidewalks are on the backs towards the bay, in terms of how that whole continuous path...
01:51:11.63 Unknown So,
01:51:12.02 Jonathon Goldman Thank you.
01:51:12.07 Unknown Thank you.
01:51:18.53 Jonathan Leone Thank you.
01:51:18.70 Jonathon Goldman that.
01:51:18.87 Jonathan Leone Thank you.
01:51:19.04 Jonathon Goldman They will get to, oh, from the fur landing to Gate 6 through Humboldt.
01:51:19.27 Jonathan Leone favorite.
01:51:23.32 Jonathan Leone From landing to gate six.
01:51:28.77 Jonathon Goldman a problem for the future.
01:51:31.64 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
01:51:31.68 Herb Weiner Thank you.

Back to the future. Okay. Is there any... Thank you, Todd. Any comment at this time from the public? Is there any public?
01:51:32.28 Jonathon Goldman Thank you.

you
01:51:42.53 Herb Weiner Thank you.
01:51:42.58 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
01:51:50.78 Jonathan Leone I'll make a motion to...

accept the status reports on the Bridgeway Path, Ferry Landing and Gate 6 Road, and Bridgeway to Ferry Landing improvements, and to Adopt the resolution of the City Council of the City of Sausalito authorizing the city engineer to advertise for construction bids for the bridgeway to ferry landing improvements.

but it, But the Filbert stairs that you're referencing here for bids and the Filbert stairs project which have NMTP numbers which I don't, we need to read those as specified in the staff report.
01:52:29.19 Herb Weiner Mr. Shepard.

Second.
01:52:30.22 Carolyn Ford My second.
01:52:30.94 Herb Weiner Okay, all in favor? Aye. Aye. Opposed? Okay, thank you, Todd.
01:52:33.46 Linda Pfeifer Bye.

Thank you.
01:52:38.91 Herb Weiner Next item is to award the contract for construction of the South Carolina.

Thank you.

Thank you.

Thank you.
01:52:46.55 Jonathon Goldman I have five minutes, Mr. Mayor.
01:52:46.57 Herb Weiner I have five minutes, Mr. Mayor.

Thank you.

.

Thank you.

Yeah.

Thank you.
01:52:56.15 Linda Pfeifer THE END OF THE END OF THE
01:52:56.41 Herb Weiner .
01:52:56.49 Linda Pfeifer laughter
01:53:09.96 Linda Pfeifer Oh.
01:53:21.80 Jonathon Goldman your Public Works Director. I have the honor of presenting this item 6D in your agenda packet this evening.
01:53:22.56 Mary Wagner Thank you.

I have
01:53:36.05 Jonathon Goldman just very briefly with Resolution No. 5195 of November 23, 2010.

The City Council found that the proposed South Salido Yacht Harbor Bay Street bulkhead construction
01:53:46.31 Mary Wagner Thank you.
01:53:46.41 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
01:53:46.44 Mary Wagner Thank you.
01:53:50.27 Jonathon Goldman was exempt from design review under the City Zoning Ordinance.

found that the proposed project was exempt from the application of the California Environmental Quality Act, pursuant to both Section 15302 and 15268, and directed that a notice of exemption be filed as provided for under said California Code of Regulations.

With that resolution, the Council also adopted the plans, specifications, and other details for said project and authorized the City Manager to invite bids for construction of the project. On December 3rd, 2010, staff issued formal invitations to bid in conformance with our Sausalito Municipal Code section on formal bids, including advertisement and trade journals, plan rooms, newspapers, and direct mail to all of the firms that expressed interest in serving the city.
01:54:26.47 Mary Wagner Right.
01:54:47.55 Jonathon Goldman Pre-bid conferences were held Thursday, December 9, 2010, and Thursday, January 13, 2011. A total of three addenda to the original plans and specs were issued, including one that extended the bid opening date to January 21, 2011.
01:54:52.90 Mary Wagner June 13, 2011.
01:55:06.58 Jonathon Goldman Bids were received from a number of bidders. They're tabulated here, and you'll have to forgive me for not having counted how many bidders there were, but certainly the bidding was well attended. There was a lot of diverse interest from not only the Bay Area construction community, but also from construction companies well outside the Bay Area. The lowest three bidders, Ray's Construction out of Pomona, was the apparent low bidder, $4,221,248. Gordon N. Ball.

$4,262,500, and West Bay Builders, $4,272,166.

Thank you.
01:55:54.66 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
01:55:55.18 Jonathon Goldman Three apparent low bids have been evaluated and found A to be responsive to the plans and specifications issued and B submitted by responsible bidders.

The low bidder, Ray's construction, is current and active in good standing as a licensed contractor in the qualifications relevant to the project according to the California State Contractors Licensing Board website.

The low bid exceeds the May 2009 engineer's estimate for the project of $4.1 million.

further, the May 2009 estimate included $374,000 for contingencies.

And The bid does not include the lumber to be used to replace the boardwalk and railing.

Areas of change to the project since the May 2009 cost estimate was prepared include Increased levels of insurance coverage being required of the contractor owing to the sensitive location and timing of the project.

Um, the request that the contractor deconstruct treated wood and coated hand railings to salvage rather than incur disposal costs, and the installation of a more significant fire protection system to comply with current standards and better protect both the boardwalk and improvements on the adjacent Spinnaker parcel.

The bid documents provide for an opportunity to enter into a teaming agreement with the city.

teaming consists of a voluntary effort by all parties having a major role in the project, to develop joint goals and establish a cooperative rather than an adversarial atmosphere while executing the construction project.

The objective of teaming is the effective completion of the work on schedule, within budget, and in accordance with the contract documents. To initiate the teaming process, the city and contractor meet after the notice of award confirm that both parties agree that teaming will be utilized on the project.

agreement is reached that teaming will be utilized, the parties will conduct a teaming workshop prior to the pre-construction conference.

follow-up workshops may also be held throughout the project.

All workshops may be conducted by an outside facilitator And it is expected that at the conclusion of the initial workshop, the parties will express a consensus regarding, among other things, respective goals in completing the project.

Um, The city will make the necessary arrangements for the workshops.

The contractor's costs associated with effectuating this teaming agreement Thank you.

will include attendance of appropriate personnel at the workshops. City will pay for the actual site and facilitator costs for the teaming workshop.

Staff plans to attempt to reduce the cost of certain of the bid items during the teaming discussions.

And even if the contractor elects not to enter into a teaming agreement, staff expects to be able to reduce the project costs.

to account for the award of the contract, account for the expenditures encumbered to date for additional design and pre-bid construction management services, and to provide for anticipated post-bid construction management services engineer services during construction, Charges anticipated from Pacific Gas and Electric American Telephone and Telegraph.

and Marin Municipal Water District, and contingencies.

Staff estimates that an additional appropriation of $878,373 is needed to deliver the project allocated as tabulated below.

amounts are there.

We're requesting Supplemental Appropriation for the bid amount over budget of $21,248.

Contingency of 5% or $211,062, $135,000 for lumber.

Construction management during construction estimated at this point at $211,062.

Um, an allowance for pre-bid construction management and legal fees of $100,000.

and an estimate of utility costs of $100,000, as well as engineering services during construction at $100,000.

The resulting total project budget, assuming the additional appropriation, is therefore $5,078,373.

As indicated during the course of Council's regular meeting of January 25, 2011, the financing necessary for the delivery of the project is in place.

The permits necessary from resource regulatory agencies for the project have been received and are in full force and effect. The notice of exemption was posted with the county recorder and submitted to the state clearinghouse in early December.

The 30-day comment period for the notice has run, and no comments have been received.

The bid recommended for award exceeds the unencumbered funds, as I mentioned a few minutes ago.

And So staff is requesting A supplemental appropriation of $878,373.
02:01:08.04 Jonathon Goldman Staff recommends and has prepared the attached resolution Um, incorporating approval that the Council authorized the City Manager to approve any combination of change orders such that the total obligation of the city under this authorization shall not exceed the budgeted amount.

In other words, if council does, adopt or approve a supplemental appropriation and we're working against a total project budget of $5,078,373, we're asking that the city manager have the authority to expend up to that budget amount.

not only the construction contract but also the other, the expense, the contingency funds things like that, certainly with information that would come back to Council, but in the interest of facilitating delivery of the project, that he have that authority.

So our recommendation this evening is that Council again find the project exempt from application of California Environmental Quality Act.

that the financing necessary is in place.

appropriate the additional funds, and award the contract for construction of the Sausalito Yacht Harbor Bay Street bulkhead project to raise construction of Pomona, California.
02:02:29.92 Herb Weiner Any questions at this time? Council Member Leon?
02:02:35.45 Linda Pfeifer Go ahead.

Thank you.
02:02:36.91 Herb Weiner I'm sorry.
02:02:36.94 Linda Pfeifer I'm sorry.
02:02:37.65 Mike Kelly Can you, in half a dozen sentences, or less, describe the qualifications of raised construction to do this project and experience?
02:02:37.70 Linda Pfeifer Can you say?

in
02:02:41.41 Adam Politzer Yeah.
02:02:41.63 Herb Weiner Alas.
02:02:49.36 Jonathon Goldman Um, half a dozen sentences.
02:02:55.33 Unknown Just use simple words.
02:02:56.33 Jonathon Goldman So we're...

Thank you.

Thank you.
02:02:58.15 Unknown Thank you.
02:02:58.20 Jonathon Goldman Thank you.
02:02:58.24 Unknown Thank you.
02:02:59.98 Jonathon Goldman The best answer to that question would be, and if I fail to deliver completely, I think there are others in the audience who'd be willing to speak to that. Ray's Construction is currently performing very similar services for local governments, municipalities, the federal government in locations throughout California including some nearby, Travis Air Force Base. They listed project references in their bid that are very similar in general to the kinds of things that we're doing here.

They demonstrated, in my judgment, based on how the bid amounts break out, a clear understanding of the details of the project, the insurance details, which many of our bidders did not.
02:03:45.86 Mary Wagner basically.
02:03:56.54 Jonathon Goldman Their website is also an excellent source of information on their experience. I'm trying to remember correctly, but I believe that they have 23 years of experience in heavy and marine construction.
02:03:59.58 Mary Wagner excellent source of information.
02:04:11.54 Mike Kelly Good. Thank you.
02:04:15.25 Herb Weiner Any other questions?
02:04:16.96 Jonathan Leone Jonathan, I think I have four.
02:04:22.41 Herb Weiner It kind of feels like you're talking to yourself when you say Jonathan, don't you?
02:04:25.04 Jonathan Leone THE END OF THE END OF THE Four questions. The replacement of the boardwalk as a wooden structure along the waterfront there, is there a need to do so to be exempt from CEQA or wouldn't the city be saving itself and the
02:04:26.71 Herb Weiner of this.
02:04:27.45 Unknown Thank you.
02:04:48.08 Jonathan Leone Madden's if we just went with a sidewalk with necessary railings and you'd get away from the ADA problems of having to get up to a raised boardwalk. There's no need for a boardwalk that sits on the ground.

I'm wondering why we're replacing that.

Thank you.

Here.
02:05:04.60 Jonathon Goldman Thank you.

Um, I hear your question, I understand your question, and I wouldn't necessarily, I'm not going to speculate at this point as to whether change, a replacement not in kind would or would not pass a CEQA test or a design review test in our planning commission or something like that. But the fact is that the The materials that we are planning to procure for replacing what's there will certainly be not only in character with what's there now, but I think will represent an improvement. Specifically, instead of painted railings, we're proposing to acquire relatively expensive wood, Port Orford cedar, which does not have to be painted and which will have a much longer life than, for example, Douglas fir or even yellow cedar or western red cedar wood.
02:05:45.27 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
02:06:01.43 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
02:06:07.93 Mary Wagner Thank you.
02:06:18.54 Jonathon Goldman What we have done is designed a project to replace what's there, and that's the information that the marketplace has bid on. So in a way, what we're trying to do is deliver the best replacement project that we can without really addressing that question. I do want to make one point, though.
02:06:26.86 Mary Wagner Thank you.

Thank you.
02:06:50.18 Jonathon Goldman I alluded to it in the staff report, because the railings are coated, painted, because the boardwalk itself is pressure treated, we were concerned because the details of disposition of those wastes had not been addressed in great detail in the design.

We did do lead-based paint testing on the coatings and fortunately found that, contrary to a number of other things that I've tested in the time that I've been here, the lead concentrations are not high enough to have created a disposal problem. But again, because the pressure treated wood had not been thoroughly vetted into the design, we asked the contractors not to plan. pressure treated wood had not been thoroughly vetted into the design, we asked the contractors not to plan on Um, demolishing and disposing of that wood. We asked them to give us a price for deconstructing it so that we could salvage anything that's usable. We are partners, the Sausalito Yacht Harbor and the city.
02:07:46.28 Carolyn Ford Thank you.
02:07:46.29 Mary Wagner Thank you.
02:07:46.31 Carolyn Ford Thank you.
02:07:46.34 Mary Wagner Thank you.
02:07:46.36 Carolyn Ford Thank you.
02:07:46.51 Mary Wagner Thank you.
02:07:58.31 Jonathon Goldman the price that we pay for that deconstruction is a line item in the bid. And it is way too much money to pay.
02:08:02.83 Mary Wagner Right.

money.

Thank you.
02:08:06.32 Jonathan Leone I just hope.
02:08:08.87 Jonathon Goldman alone is one area where we will be working very closely with the contractor to try to optimize that bid item and that process so that we aren't spending a significant amount of money to deconstruct and instead are, you know, making the best use of the dollars and whatever salvage we can realize. Right. Well, my point with that,
02:08:28.84 Unknown Thank you.

Thank you.

Thank you.
02:08:31.97 Jonathan Leone that is not I don't think it's a subjective comment, I would imagine, but to have a boardwalk on a parking lot, or a blacktop, which is essentially what's there, is, you know, you know, having a boardwalk that's over water is, you can understand why it's a, I can call it a boardwalk, it's an elevated platform. There's no need for it once you regrade and repave this parcel. So why have one at all? Just have a railing that's a safety factor, whatever material's appropriate.
02:08:56.21 Linda Pfeifer Yeah.
02:09:07.87 Jonathan Leone and save yourself the money and save yourself the maintenance and whatever ADA problems of rise and run You know, that's a good example why you don't want to put one of those in, because after a good number of years, you're going to have the same problems whatever material you put there. So is there an opportunity to save money, still have a walkway that's picturesque, just using just grade, at grade, versus six inches or 12 inches above grade?
02:09:22.70 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
02:09:31.59 Jonathon Goldman Thank you.

Thank you.
02:09:36.10 Jonathon Goldman Yeah, we can certainly look at that, but my instinct is that there probably isn't without
02:09:40.10 Jonathan Leone Bye.
02:09:42.88 Jonathon Goldman that being a change to the project. The only other point I'll make in defense of the elevation of the boardwalk that's there now is that when the bulkhead and other areas of that point are inundated by flooding, the boardwalk will still be dry.
02:10:04.19 Jonathan Leone Thank you.
02:10:04.52 Jonathon Goldman Uh,
02:10:04.97 Jonathan Leone Whereas if it gets that high, we got a lot of bigger issues, then the 12 inches you're going to gain, but that boardwalk
02:10:05.33 Jonathon Goldman I forget.
02:10:07.62 Unknown or issues.
02:10:11.86 Jonathan Leone Like with the rest of the property and the park and the Spinnaker. I mean, if you look at the BC maps, Spinnaker ain't going to be there, you know, end of century. So this elevated piece may be there, but there's nothing past it halfway down that peninsula. So anyway, but I think that would give you, you know you some way to get back within budget. And it's an unnecessary use of funds unless there's some historic or other. My guess is that actually isn't all that old what's there, but who knows.
02:10:11.92 Mary Wagner Thank you.
02:10:11.94 Adam Politzer Uh...
02:10:17.78 Mary Wagner Yes.

Thank you.
02:10:29.02 Mary Wagner So...
02:10:48.14 Jonathon Goldman I'm certainly willing to take that into teaming workshops with the contractor and our designers and our planning staff, and if it becomes a viable way of saving money, we'll
02:11:04.09 Jonathan Leone Well, and that drives the way it's also phrased in here. It becomes the need for fire suppression, right, which currently doesn't exist there. And I would argue that fire suppression is not a replacement of the existing projects.

that if it's fire suppression for the dock facilities.

which I think is how it's phrased here, it's gonna hang off, it's gonna supply both, then that's the responsibility of the owner of the marina, which those docks are not part of our responsibility capital-wise, so any fire suppression should be their responsibility and not part of this project.
02:11:35.69 Jonathon Goldman No.

Thank you.
02:11:36.15 Jonathan Leone Thank you.
02:11:36.18 Jonathon Goldman Uh,
02:11:36.48 Jonathan Leone Thank you.
02:11:36.52 Jonathon Goldman Okay.

I disagree because we're constructing facilities that are adjacent to other city facilities like the Spinnaker, and no matter what happens on our tenants' property, if we have the infrastructure in place to put out a fire on our boardwalk or on our Spinnaker restaurant, we're going
02:11:50.83 Mary Wagner matter.
02:12:00.58 Jonathan Leone or on the Spinnaker restaurant. A fire plug is different than fire suppression so it's which is kind of, it implies something greater. It's a wet standpipe system.
02:12:11.03 Jonathon Goldman It's just an extension of the same kind of hose cabinets that we have here in City Hall so that in the event that there is a fire, any individual can open a hose cabinet and turn a valve and put water on the fire right away instead of waiting for a fire engine to respond. And it's actually, we can certainly take it up with the city attorney and our partners as to whether the cost should be divided differently. But the plan check comments on the original set of plans were that the fire,
02:12:35.89 Mary Wagner the City Attorney and our partners.
02:12:47.92 Jonathon Goldman the provisions for fire suppression in the original plans were inadequate, so we've responded to those comments with a more detailed fire system.
02:12:58.36 Jonathan Leone Thank you.
02:12:58.99 Jonathon Goldman Thank you.
02:12:59.00 Jonathan Leone I'm not arguing against fire safety, it's who pays for it. Yeah. So is it the operator of the facility or is it an infrastructure?
02:12:59.05 Jonathon Goldman Are you...
02:13:01.85 Unknown Yeah.
02:13:06.65 Unknown Thank you.
02:13:06.73 Mary Wagner Thank you.
02:13:06.78 Unknown Thank you.
02:13:09.60 Mary Wagner Councilor Murillo, just to clarify, we can certainly, as Jonathan indicated, work with Sausalito Yacht Harbor to the extent that there are improvements in that fire suppression system that relate solely to the docks and don't serve to protect the peninsula as a whole. We can address that with them. I don't anticipate a big problem.

but my recollection is similar.

to Mr. Goldman that this is a comment from the fire department that related to fire suppression for the entire peninsula that they were concerned about the ability to get out there and have the appropriate equipment in place. That being said, I think we can go back and look at that and with that specific issue in mind. The only other comment I had was on the the boardwalk issue, Mr. Mayor and Councilmembers. We'd need to also look at the permitting, you know, the BCDC permitting and the other permits that have been obtained and ensure that we're in compliance with those as well.
02:14:07.04 Jonathan Leone Thank you.
02:14:07.06 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
02:14:07.08 Jonathan Leone Thank you.

And the teaming, has that been something you've had discussions yet with the contractor in terms of their willingness to do that as an up front concept rather than the way this is phrased, it's discussed after the bid is awarded?
02:14:19.11 Jonathon Goldman We have had some discussions. The contractor is not obligated to enter into a teaming agreement with us. And certainly given that council hasn't awarded the contract, I'm sure that any of those discussions are relatively informal at this point. But I have satisfied myself personally that we are dealing with a responsible and committed contractor who's well aware of the process, teaming and partnering, and has very successfully used those processes and other projects to realize the very same objectives that I think are ours on this project.
02:15:00.18 Herb Weiner Thank you.

Any other questions?
02:15:02.92 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
02:15:04.33 Herb Weiner Okay, thank you, Jonathan. Just not here, any comments from the public?

Thank you.

Bring it back, Garcia.
02:15:14.22 Linda Pfeifer move that we...
02:15:16.05 Jonathan Leone Can I just ask, are you representing the Reyes construction? Can I just ask you about the teaming concept? And if you need to, unfortunately, be on the microphone. If you've practiced that before, and is it something that's become part of the
02:15:16.70 Herb Weiner Thank you.
02:15:26.02 Herb Weiner if you practice
02:15:31.03 Unknown normal normal business. Yes. We are engaged in several projects where we've got a formal partnering process, probably more extensive than what I envision is going to happen here.

We're also involved in projects where it is not a requirement of the contract and we still promote it. We're looking forward to building this nice project in this beautiful city and we want it to be a successful project. When we get done, one of the measures of success for us will be that you want us to come back and build another project.
02:15:45.17 Mary Wagner Thank you.

you
02:16:08.51 Unknown So we're well aware of the, we call it partnering, but very happy to participate in a teaming arrangement. Very happy to participate in any way we can to contribute positively to reductions and changes in the project. And we hope to receive an award and move forward.
02:16:26.13 Mary Wagner Thank you.
02:16:26.14 Mike Kelly and changes in the project.
02:16:31.97 Mike Kelly Thank you.
02:16:31.98 Unknown Thank you.
02:16:32.03 Mike Kelly Thank you.
02:16:32.12 Unknown to get to the next level.
02:16:32.29 Mike Kelly Thank you.

Thank you.
02:16:32.98 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
02:16:33.03 Mike Kelly Thank you.

I move we adopt a resolution to City Council, City Sausalito, to finding the project categorically exempt from application of the California Environmental Quality Act and awarding the contract for construction.

of the Yacht Harbor Bay Street bulkhead replacement project.

I'm not sure.
02:16:48.57 Carolyn Ford One second.
02:16:48.64 Herb Weiner Second.

Thank you.

Thank you.

Okay. All in favor? Aye. Opposed?
02:16:51.41 Carolyn Ford I
02:16:54.34 Jonathan Leone I'm going to abstain on this one because there's nothing wrong with you as a contractor. I don't like this project because of the finances underneath of it, and I hope you do a great job. I'm sure you will, and thank you for your bid. But the design, the sharing of costs, the future maintenance costs and capital cost sharing, the legal ownership of land and streets, and none of that's addressed with any of this, and the city's lost any and all leverage in negotiating those, including what we were just relating to the projects before this as a result of this. So I'm going to abstain on this.
02:17:28.90 Mike Kelly Any other reasons?
02:17:30.03 Jonathan Leone Uh...
02:17:30.64 Mike Kelly Good.
02:17:30.98 Unknown Uh...

.
02:17:34.25 Jonathan Leone That's all? The possibility that this whole, the possibility that this half his bulkhead's going to be underwater before the useful life.
02:17:35.47 Unknown that this whole, that the possible
02:17:37.96 Linda Pfeifer Yeah.

Bye.

.
02:17:44.56 Herb Weiner We'll all be underwater by that time.
02:17:47.63 Linda Pfeifer Okay.
02:17:48.53 Herb Weiner Thank you very much. Congratulations. You got it.
02:17:54.97 Mike Kelly Thank you. Okay.
02:17:55.67 Herb Weiner Thank you. Okay, I think we're finished at that end. Now let's see.
02:17:59.85 Mike Kelly That being said, I was
02:18:00.97 Jonathan Leone Thank you.
02:18:01.49 Mike Kelly Thank you.
02:18:01.54 Herb Weiner He'll be down there every day, don't worry about it. No, he'll be down there every day. Okay, at that time, at this time here, city manager's report, please.
02:18:01.64 Mike Kelly Thank you.
02:18:01.98 Jonathan Leone Ha ha!
02:18:02.43 Linda Pfeifer I'm not.
02:18:02.77 Jonathan Leone Thank you.
02:18:02.87 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
02:18:02.91 Jonathan Leone He'll be down there every day, don't worry about it.

He'll be down in the back of the day.
02:18:16.07 Adam Politzer Just three very quick items. I just wanted to confirm the strategic planning retreat is set as we discussed it at last week's council meeting for Friday, March 25th. And also would like to announce that we will be having a special city council meeting to officially meet and greet our new police chief on st. Patrick's Day March 17th at 4 p.m. our new chief is Irish and from Ireland and thought that that would be a very appropriate day so that will be at the bay model from 4 to roughly 530 and we'll open the meeting as a council meeting we'll swear in our new chief and the chief will say a few words and then we'll have a nice reception where people have an opportunity to meet Jennifer Tejada and then last is at the conclusion of tonight's meeting, I'll be heading down to Monterey for the City Managers Conference and will be there through Friday afternoon. That concludes my report.
02:18:51.13 Mary Wagner Our new chair.
02:19:29.31 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
02:19:29.32 Herb Weiner Thank you.

Moving on to the next item, which is appointments. I just had two.
02:19:38.69 Mike Kelly And I want to make a motion too, so go ahead.
02:19:40.73 Herb Weiner Okay, one is the legislative committee, and that will be myself and Council Member Jonathan Leone. And two, just reaffirm the...

Linda.
02:19:58.47 Unknown to go.
02:20:01.98 Herb Weiner Thank you. And that would be Linda Feiffer. Council member Feiffer.
02:20:07.19 Mike Kelly I'D LIKE TO MAKE A MOTION AND WE CAN DISCUSS IT. THE MOTION WOULD BE TO DIRECT STAFF TO BRING BACK A RESOLUTION CLARIFYING THE HOUSING ELEMENT COMMITTEE BY DESIGNATING IT AS A TASK FORCE WITH THE SOLE PURPOSE UNDER THE DIRECTION OF THE COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT, THE SOLE PURPOSE TO ASSIST IN THE PREPARATION OF THE DRAFT HOUSING ELEMENT FOR PRESENTATION TO THE CITY COUNCIL.

The task force would not be subject to Section 2.58 something-something-something. You'll figure that one out, right?

Okay? And, um, The task force would have nine members selected and approved by the Council.

Thank you.

The mayor would appoint the council, the council members would be appointed by the mayor, the council members representing which they have been. And the mayor would also appoint the chair and vice chair of the committee. Nine members would be two council members, two planning members, planning commission members, and five citizens. Once the work is completed, the committee, or the task force I should say, would be dissolved. So it's a single purpose entity with not...

falling underneath the regular boards and commissions that we
02:21:22.00 Carolyn Ford How many members are on? Nine. Right. Oh, I see.
02:21:23.55 Mike Kelly 9. Oh, I see. There's only 8, but it's authorized for 9. I see. Oh, okay. So everything is constituted the same. He said that we're moving it from a regular committee, which is not, because it's not of, you know, Boards and Commissions, Park Recreation, that kind of thing, to a special purpose entity. Okay. And it just clarifies it, I think, for everybody concerned.
02:21:27.21 Carolyn Ford I see.
02:21:28.27 Linda Pfeifer Thank you very much.
02:21:28.95 Carolyn Ford So,
02:21:29.02 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
02:21:29.07 Carolyn Ford Okay.
02:21:30.42 Unknown The Constitution of the State.

We're moving it.
02:21:41.12 Linda Pfeifer you
02:21:44.73 Linda Pfeifer No issue. So what you're just saying is you're clarifying that it's a task force. It's not a... So what's the difference? I mean, it's an ad... It's called an ad hoc committee, right?
02:21:45.72 Unknown Thank you.
02:21:50.97 Mike Kelly Peace.

It's called an ad.

Well, the wording of it, this is given a specificity which fits underneath the code. Right now, if you read 2.58, whatever it is, it doesn't match any of the descriptions of that because those are for continuing committees that move and meet regularly and conduct city
02:22:00.83 Unknown Thank you.
02:22:00.84 Linda Pfeifer Mm-hmm.
02:22:01.13 Unknown Thank you.

Thank you.
02:22:03.86 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
02:22:05.25 Unknown Okay.
02:22:09.58 Unknown Thank you.

Those are
02:22:17.90 Mike Kelly across their stated purpose, but they go on and on and on.

This one doesn't have any term limits for its people, like we stagger the term limits, all that other stuff. So it just clarifies it and brings it into a focus that we can deal with.
02:22:21.77 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
02:22:21.97 Mary Wagner Absolutely.

Thank you.
02:22:23.03 Carolyn Ford Right.

I don't know.

I love you.
02:22:32.25 Carolyn Ford Okay, are there any other major differences between a task force and a committee? Okay, sounds good.
02:22:36.68 Mike Kelly No, I'm aware of it.
02:22:38.00 Carolyn Ford Okay.
02:22:38.44 Mike Kelly Thank you.

Do you have a motion? I'll get a motion on your seat.
02:22:44.77 Herb Weiner All in favor.

Aye. Aye. Opposed?
02:22:46.03 Mike Kelly Thank you.

Bye.
02:22:46.47 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
02:22:48.70 Herb Weiner Okay, perfect.

Thank you.

I'm a future agenda item.
02:22:54.49 Linda Pfeifer Mr. Mayor?
02:22:55.33 Herb Weiner Thank you.
02:22:55.38 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
02:22:56.89 Herb Weiner Thank you.
02:22:57.51 Linda Pfeifer You are very consistent. And when you say
02:23:03.97 Herb Weiner What are we doing system?

And when you say so, I know it's going to come out.
02:23:10.70 Linda Pfeifer I mentioned this before, I will just repeat that I hope to see a
02:23:16.04 Linda Pfeifer Hmm.

Thank you.
02:23:17.25 Herb Weiner Thank you.
02:23:17.30 Linda Pfeifer The last, the last,
02:23:25.83 Linda Pfeifer on the agenda confirmation of the BAC economic study staying within current zoning designations. And another future agenda item I'm interested in, I'll say it and then I'll explain what I mean, is transparency on MLK finance restructuring. At last week's council meeting when Charlie presented, you know, on the actuary studies and answered our questions with respect to the pension.

He mentioned a couple of options with respect to, you know, how we might be able to, how the city might be able to, handled.

the pension liabilities.

And he mentioned MLK.

MLK finance restructuring, and I didn't know what that meant. And so I had a meeting with him last week, And I am...

I- I just, in learning about this, it raised a lot of questions that I had.

and some concerns, and it just seemed like it might be appropriate to bring it to light and discuss it.
02:24:44.14 Herb Weiner Thank you.

All right.

Any other items?
02:24:48.93 Carolyn Ford I just have one question.

The BAC committee report, when is that going to be presented? Do we know? The reason I'm asking is I have a meeting with Rob Eiler for February 17th, and I just want to make sure I meet with him before we hear it.
02:24:55.26 Herb Weiner Thank you.
02:24:58.57 Mary Wagner Thank you.
02:24:58.59 Unknown Thank you.
02:24:58.76 Mary Wagner THE REASON I THINK
02:25:09.13 Carolyn Ford Yeah.
02:25:10.21 Adam Politzer At the last council meeting, we received that request by the council and there was discussion and the community development director and I had that discussion last week. And it's my understanding that we'll be inviting Rob Eiler to come to the council meeting, bring this report forward, make sure that we're clear on what they're to be working on and give an update.
02:25:37.30 Mike Kelly It's the scope. It's the scope.
02:25:40.05 Adam Politzer I think one of the things that he's working on now is he's been trying to contact each of the council members to meet with you and I think that may be one of the things that you'll be discussing council member Ford with him but also with the business community and residents just trying to get an understanding. So I'm hoping that he also tells us what he's been doing not just come and ask clarification. But obviously that is the main thrust of him coming is to clarify what the scope of his work is and to make sure that he gets clear direction from the council.

I don't know if that's the 15th or the 8th of March. It's... Oh, it's in March. Well, there seem to be some interest in having it as soon as possible. So the earliest would be the 15th. The most likely is the 8th, but I would have to go back and look at the draft agenda and see if it's on, where it is, if it's on there.
02:26:44.76 Linda Pfeifer and
02:26:45.03 Carolyn Ford Okay, well, the problem that I'm having then with that is that I can't meet with him until the 17th of February. And I do want to have a conversation with him before we hear it here. Could we move to the audience?
02:27:04.07 Unknown that's
02:27:04.29 Herb Weiner Thank you.
02:27:04.32 Unknown Thank you.
02:27:04.37 Herb Weiner Thank you.
02:27:04.42 Unknown Thank you.
02:27:04.46 Herb Weiner you
02:27:04.59 Unknown So,
02:27:04.83 Herb Weiner you
02:27:05.12 Carolyn Ford Thank you.
02:27:05.18 Herb Weiner Thank you.
02:27:05.20 Carolyn Ford Bye.
02:27:05.56 Herb Weiner you
02:27:05.72 Carolyn Ford Thank you.
02:27:05.74 Herb Weiner Thank you.
02:27:05.79 Unknown Thank you.
02:27:05.98 Carolyn Ford Thank you.
02:27:06.03 Herb Weiner Thank you.
02:27:06.35 Carolyn Ford you
02:27:06.60 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
02:27:06.74 Carolyn Ford Thank you.
02:27:06.89 Unknown Thank you.
02:27:07.14 Adam Politzer So if there's consensus for the council to push that to the A. Are you saying first?
02:27:10.15 Herb Weiner Thank you.
02:27:10.38 Mike Kelly Thank you.
02:27:10.40 Herb Weiner No, it's February 15th. It would have to be on the March 8th.
02:27:13.15 Adam Politzer The President. The President.

If there's consensus to move it to March 8th, well, that's what we'll be aiming for.
02:27:20.20 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
02:27:20.66 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
02:27:20.67 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.

Yeah, and I would just to reiterate that, I'm meeting with him tomorrow, and it's important to me that it happen on March.
02:27:22.08 Linda Pfeifer Yeah.
02:27:32.81 Linda Pfeifer There you go.

8th and not the 15th because the Saucydo Women's Club Jinx is on the March 15th.

Thank you.

In a minute.
02:27:44.23 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
02:27:44.25 Mike Kelly In our minutes. March 15th started. That was, you meant February 15th, didn't you?
02:27:50.59 Linda Pfeifer Oh, February 15th, okay.
02:27:52.03 Mike Kelly Okay. Well, there I just.
02:27:52.69 Linda Pfeifer Well, there I just...
02:27:53.92 Jonathan Leone Thank you.
02:27:54.05 Linda Pfeifer you Okay, never mind, forget.
02:27:54.32 Mike Kelly Please.
02:27:54.83 Linda Pfeifer Okay.
02:27:55.24 Mike Kelly Thank you.
02:27:55.27 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
02:27:55.37 Jonathan Leone Thank you.
02:27:56.25 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
02:27:56.45 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
02:27:56.52 Linda Pfeifer Yeah.
02:27:56.60 Jonathan Leone Thank you.
02:27:56.62 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
02:27:56.70 Jonathan Leone Thank you.

Thank you.
02:27:57.02 Linda Pfeifer .
02:27:57.23 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
02:27:57.26 Linda Pfeifer Oh, see.
02:27:58.10 Jonathan Leone You said March. Yeah. It's going to come February 15th.

Thank you.
02:28:02.41 Adam Politzer I don't know if he's willing to come on February 15th. Staff took from the last... Staff took from the council meeting... It's worse than me.
02:28:03.10 Jonathan Leone No.

15th. Staff took from the last... It's generally very hard to get to do anything. Staff took from the council meeting... It's worse than me. Because I'll just tell you to your face that he won't do it.
02:28:16.16 Adam Politzer Staff took from the last council meeting a request to bring him forward as soon as possible. The soonest possible would be February 15th. What I think we're hearing today is March P.
02:28:16.31 Jonathan Leone Steph.
02:28:27.74 Unknown hearing today is Marchable.
02:28:31.35 Mike Kelly I think I remember from the BAC meeting that March 8th was the time he wanted to do it because they figured they could be ready to come and talk at that point. So I believe that's what's on their minds, not necessarily on our mind. So that was...
02:28:36.63 Linda Pfeifer the time he wanted to.

I'm going to be right.
02:28:40.04 Jonathan Leone I'm sorry.
02:28:40.49 Linda Pfeifer and the government.
02:28:40.86 Jonathan Leone Thank you.
02:28:46.58 Jonathan Leone He commented that clearly.
02:28:48.07 Mike Kelly No, no, no, no. He would come here on March 8th.
02:28:51.26 Jonathan Leone Thank you.
02:28:51.73 Mike Kelly So I think that's...

I think you'll find that's the date he has in mind.
02:28:55.11 Herb Weiner Thank you.

Okay.

Um...

Council member of committee reports.

I'm not finished putting all Bye.
02:29:05.82 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
02:29:05.94 Herb Weiner the positions that I want and things.

I'm not really pushing for for reports yet, but I will in the very near future be asking for reports on these committees.
02:29:21.79 Unknown Thank you.
02:29:21.87 Herb Weiner Thank you.
02:29:22.02 Jonathan Leone I'll just give you a couple quick ones so I can say I did it. The
02:29:25.25 Unknown the
02:29:31.05 Jonathan Leone As you know, there were at least one person down at HLB, so if we could get that. And I think there's some people who have applied for the Planning Commission that we might ask to consider the HLB vacancy, and maybe you can...
02:29:34.98 Mary Wagner Thank you.

Thank you.
02:29:45.82 Herb Weiner Mr. Pogba, what, subpoena subpoena?
02:29:48.11 Jonathan Leone Yeah, because he'd moved. Okay.
02:29:49.53 Herb Weiner Yeah.

Thank you.
02:29:52.03 Jonathan Leone that's that vacancy.
02:29:52.97 Herb Weiner Is there another vacancy then? Not currently. There's some terms
02:29:55.69 Jonathan Leone Not currently. There's some terms terming out in the April, May time frame.
02:29:58.71 Herb Weiner and So we need to fill that in.
02:30:03.16 Mike Kelly Yeah, because.
02:30:03.28 Herb Weiner Thank you.
02:30:03.30 Jonathan Leone Yeah, because they're doing this whole ship and the guidelines and stuff.
02:30:03.84 Herb Weiner it's a good thing.
02:30:05.73 Mike Kelly and chip on the guidelines. Yeah, plus the work on the VA building. Right, that's what I mean.
02:30:09.54 Jonathan Leone Right, that's what I mean. So that would be, I think there's some qualified planning commission applicants who might want to consider asking if they would do that, and I'd be happy to talk to you about that list.
02:30:13.48 Mike Kelly Qualified.
02:30:22.13 Jonathan Leone The Marin Energy Authority, just to give you a quick two seconds, so as you may, a lot of this has been in the paper, but so they, you know. I see you on TV.
02:30:27.14 Mary Wagner A lot of this.

you know,
02:30:30.10 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
02:30:32.19 Jonathan Leone I've got to stop going to that meeting. So they let two contracts out for landfill gas, which, you know, late pricing discussion aside, they're sort of trying to fulfill their component of green, and those are considered green. They hired the...
02:30:33.73 Linda Pfeifer Thank you.
02:30:53.22 Jonathan Leone directorship to Don Weiss, the existing interim director, and actually much more reasonable than they were going to have to pay an outside person to come in. And by and large, I have to say, they have really changed
02:30:55.83 Mary Wagner as a director.
02:31:08.72 Jonathan Leone I don't feel like I'm fighting uphill as much at those meetings because they finally realized there's only so much money and you can't do everything. So let's focus on running this utility. And if we get grants and other things, then you'll do a lot of the energy efficiency programs. But that's the political aspect of it. So I think that there is a functioning entity that's in a much better place than it was six months ago. It's in a very good place. How are you doing? And so I think it was worth bringing that to your
02:31:17.09 Mary Wagner You too.
02:31:24.49 Mary Wagner But that's...
02:31:25.48 Unknown It's really cold.
02:31:37.31 Unknown Um...
02:31:43.23 Herb Weiner .

That's it.

I think.
02:31:45.85 Jonathan Leone Thank you.
02:31:47.00 Herb Weiner All right. Any predictions on the Super Bowl while we're up here? With that, we can adjourn.
02:31:52.60 Carolyn Ford Yeah.

Thank you.
02:31:56.99 Carolyn Ford And we did well.

Oh, my God. I think he said, right?
02:31:58.15 Herb Weiner Oh, my God. I think he said,